The transcriptional and epigenetic mechanisms underlying the generation of new neurons from neural stem cells in the subgranular layer of the dentate gyrus (DG) are well established in rodents 11. Neurogenesis is tightly regulated by the local circuitry, specifically, GABAergic input 12,13. Parvalbumin-expressing interneurons (PVs) in the DG regulate neurogenesis in an activity- dependent manner 14. Immature neurons form transient but strong connections with inhibitory neurons in the DG and CA3, which are important for learning 15. Hippocampal neurogenesis plays critical roles in learning and memory in the rodent brain 1,2. Immature neurons get recruited into memory circuits and play important roles in memory formation 9,16-18. Neurogenesis is reduced in the aging rodent, impaired in mouse models of Alzheimer’s disease (AD) and contributes to memory deficits 8-10,19,20. In contrast, little is known regarding the fate of neurogenesis in the human brain, let alone the mechanisms that regulate it or its function in cognition. The existence of hippocampal neurogenesis in the adult human brain has generated controversy over the past few years 21-26, primarily attributable to the limitations in the use of species- specific neurogenic proxies, sample processing, cell annotation and computational analysis 27-29. Other claims suggested that immature neurons were mistaken for inhibitory neurons 23. Using a machine-learning approach, a recent study identified the existence of immature neurons in the adult human brain 24 and validated reduced number of immature neurons in Alzheimer’s disease (AD) 25,30. However, the human DG is thought to be resilient to the development of pathology 31 and it is not clear what underlies putative shifts in the profile of neurogenesis in aging and AD. Here, we aimed to unravel the molecular and cellular signals that regulate neurogenesis in the adult human brain, and alterations to these signals and the neurogenic niche in aging and AD. To gain an insight into a possible association between neurogenesis and cognitive function, we applied joint single nuclei RNA sequencing (snRNAseq) and single nuclei Assay for Transposase-Accessible Chromatin (snATACseq) on nuclei isolated from the hippocampus of young adults (YA, n=2), aging with no cognitive impairments (NCI, n=4), mild cognitive impairments/early dementia (MCI, n=4) and Alzheimer’s disease dementia (AD, n=4) (Figure 1A, Supplemental Table 1).
Characteristics of neurogenesis in the human brain
In this pipeline, 116,068 nuclei were sequenced. Unsupervised clustering based on snRNAseq revealed 13 cell types in the hippocampus including radial glia/neural stem cells (NSCs), neuroblasts and immature neurons (Figure 1B). To ensure unbiased cell annotation, we utilized the machine learning label transfer algorithm scANVI (https://doi.org/10.15252/msb.20209620) to transfer labels from two scRNAseq datasets, a human developmental forebrain 32 and an adult human hippocampal dataset 24. We identified a total of 5,374 radial glia/neural stem cells (NSCs), 416 neuroblasts and 1,179 immature neurons (Figure 1B,C). NSC expression profile included stemness proxies, such as Slc1A2,3, Notch2, SoxB1 (Sox2,3), SoxD genes (Sox5, Sox6), SoxE (Sox9), radial glial-like proxies (GFAP, Aqp4), neural development proxies (Pax6, Ncam1) in addition to well-documented adult NSCs’ proxies (Prrx1, Rest, Lpar1 and Pdgfrb) (Figure 1C). Neuroblasts had a wide spectrum of proxies, sharing some with NSCs and others with immature neurons. Compared to neuroblasts, immature neurons expressed reduced levels of Stmn1, Stmn2 and higher levels of Prox1, Tbr1, Calb1, Ncam1, Dcx, Nnat) and synaptic plasticity and neuronal markers (Snap25, Synpr, Rbfox1,3, Kcnq5) (Figure 1C). Further, we examined the pattern of open chromatin events of key neurogenic proxies and observed that stemness signals, such as Nestin, Sox2 and Gfap show more open chromatin events in NSCs, while Dcx, Calb2 and Calb1 exhibit more open chromatin in immature neurons (Figure 1D). To further phenotype the identified neurogenic population, we performed lineage trajectory analysis and tested if these clusters follow a developmental lineage progression of hippocampal neurogenesis. CytoTRACE analysis revealed linear developmental trajectory where the NSC cluster appeared earlier in development compared to neuroblasts and immature neurons (Figure 1E). Pseudotime analysis validated that these cell types follow a continuous developmental pathway (Figure 1F). Next, we examined the expression pattern of proxies known to transiently peak at different time points in neurogenesis. LOESS-smoothed expression patterns showed that stemness proxies peaked early and were downregulated later in neurogenesis, while differentiation and neuronal maturation proxies were expressed at low levels at an early stage and peaked later in the CytoTRACE trajectory (Figure 1G). Pathway enrichment analysis against CytoTRACE time using GSEA on the NIGO pathway database33 revealed that genes and pathways involved in stem cell development were enriched earlier across the trajectory while pathways involved in neuronal maturation, morphology, differentiation, and synaptic plasticity are enriched later across the trajectory (Figure 1H,I, Supplemental Table 2,3). In the mouse subgranular zone (SGZ), signals that regulate excitability and ion channel activity were absent early in NSC stage but enriched following fate commitment and neuronal differentiation 34. Similarly, our analysis revealed that the expression of these transcripts known to convey synaptic function and plasticity, is upregulated during the neuroblast stage (Figure 1J). Together, these observations determine three neurogenic populations, NSCs, neuroblasts and immature neurons among the cellular constituents of the human hippocampus.
Transcriptomic and Epigenetic modifications drive altered profile of neurogenesis in aging and AD.
To examine a putative association between hippocampal cells, age and cognitive function, we asked whether the number or profile of these cells changed with age or cognitive diagnosis. Quantification of cell types revealed that the relative proportion of inhibitory neurons (“GABA_neurons”) and immature neurons were significantly different between diagnoses (q = 0.0258 for each) (Figure 2A,B, Supplemental Table 4). Immature neurons (q = 0.000149, p = 1.15E-5), were the only cell type that was significantly reduced in AD compared to NCI (Figure 2A,B). We confirmed the downregulation of immature neurons in AD using a separate donor cohort by immunohistochemistry and unbiased stereology (Supplemental Figure 1 and Supplemental Table 5). The number of neuroblasts (q = 0.0812, p = 0.012506) and NSCs (q = 0.2, p = 0.046) in AD compared to NCI were trending lower but did not reach statistically significance. Compared to their numbers in YA, inhibitory neurons (q = 0.005072) and immature neurons (q = 5.21E-05) were significantly reduced in AD. The number of CA1 neurons was trending but not statistically significant (p = 0.045, q= 0.142). Immature neurons were the only cell type that was reduced, trending but not statistically significant, in AD compared to MCI (q = 0.1647, p = 0.012672). The numbers of astrocytes, but not of microglia, were increased in AD, albeit not in a statistically significant manner (Figure 2A,B). Notably, previous attempts have been made to discriminate between NSCs and astrocytes in the rodent and human brains35-37. Our snRNAseq-based sequencing, machine-learning analysis and cell annotation based on both developmental and adult human hippocampal dataset revealed distinct clusters of mature astrocytes and NSCs (Figure 1B). The astrocyte cluster showed a trending increase of astrocyte numbers in AD compared to YA (q = 0.09, p = 0.022), while the numbers of NSCs in AD compared to NCI (q = 0.2, p = 0.04) and YA (q = 0.18, p = 0.09) were trending decrease (Figure 2A,B). Three proxy-based immunohistochemistry and unbiased stereology analyses showed that the number of NSCs was comparable in NCI, MCI and AD, while the number of astrocytes increased in AD compared to NCI and positively correlated with high AD pathology (NIA-Reagan criteria, Supplemental Figure 2).
To further investigate a possible association between the cell types in the hippocampus, age and diagnosis we examined whether the abundance of the DG cellular constituents correlated with AD pathological hallmarks. We observed that the extent of inhibitory neurons, immature neurons, neuroblasts, neural stem cells (NSCs) and astrocytes was associated with pathological hallmarks. Specifically, the number of immature neurons was greater in APOE e3; e3 homozygote carriers compared to APOE e3; e4 (Figure 2C). The number of immature neurons and inhibitory GABAergic neurons inversely correlated with the severity of cerebral amyloid angiopathy (CAA) (Figure 2D). The abundance of NSCs and inhibitory GABAergic neurons positively correlated with low BRAAK stage, while the number of astrocytes negatively correlated with it (Figure 2E). Likewise, the number of neuroblasts and immature neurons correlated with low neuropathology change (Figure 2F). In agreement with that, we observed an inverse correlation between the number of immature neurons and extent of neurofibrillary tangles, and positive correlation with the slope of global cognitive score (Supplemental Figure 1). Finally, the number of neuroblasts, inhibitory GABAergic neurons and CA1 neurons correlated with lower cortical neuritic plaque density (CERAD score) (Figure 2G).
To gain insight into the mechanisms of altered cell numbers, we sought to examine the profile of neurogenic cells and inhibitory neurons in YA, NCI, MCI and AD (Supplemental Table 6,7). Quantification of differentially expressed genes (DEGs) and peaks revealed that in NSC, a comparable number of DEGs were either up- or downregulated in YA or AD compared to NCI. In immature neurons, the majority of DEG were upregulated in YA compared to NCI. However, in AD, the majority of DEGs expressed in immature neurons were downregulated compared to NCI (Figure 2H). Specifically, In NSC, 64 DEGs were upregulated in YA/NCI while 70 were downregulated. In AD, 44 genes were upregulated while 144 were downregulated in NSC, compared to NCI (Figure 2H). In immature neurons, 197 were DE between YA and NCI, of them, 142 were upregulated in the YC. However, in AD, the majority of DEGs in immature neurons were downregulated. In GABA neurons, the majority of DEGs were downregulated in AD compared to NCI, with 435 genes downregulated and 289 upregulated (Figure 2H). Peak analysis revealed that 208 peaks were downregulated in NSC, but the majority of alterations in open chromatin events took place in immature neurons in AD compared to NCI; 14,211 peaks were downregulated in AD compared to NCI in immature neurons while only 5 were upregulated (Figure 2I). Only a few were significantly altered in inhibitory (Figure 2I). In NSCs we observed 208 peaks downregulated and only 7 upregulated. No significant alterations in open chromatin were observed in neuroblasts among diagnoses. This may be due to the low number of the neuroblasts population. In the case of NSC and inhibitory neurons, this may suggest that most of the alterations we could detect in these cells were of existing transcripts. Together, our data implies that first, a concerted action of transcription and epigenetic mechanisms lead to an altered profile of neurogenesis as a function of age and diagnosis. Second, substantial epigenetic alterations take place in immature neurons compared to NSCs or inhibitory neurons. Third, most transcriptional alterations in neurogenesis takes place in AD.
Neural stem cell profile is altered in aging
To gain an insight into key mechanisms regulating neurogenesis as a function of age and diagnosis, we first examined the profile of NSCs. Mammalian Adult Neurogenesis Gene Ontology (MANGO) were significantly enriched in NSC DEGs (q = 2.84X10-9). Examination of neurogenesis-related signaling in NSC across our cohort revealed that the transcription profile of YA is distinct of the other 3 diagnostic groups (Figure 3A). The transcription profile of NSCs undergoes modifications in NCI and MCI, leading to an AD profile where most genes showed the opposite expression pattern compared to YA (Figure 3A, Supplemental Figure 3, Supplemental Table 6-9). Top DEGs in YA that were downregulated in NCI included genes that play a major role in neuronal function, such as the glutamate transporter Slc1a2, Glutamate Ionotropic Receptor AMPA Type Subunit 2 Gria2 and Dab1, critical for brain development and neuronal migration (Figure 3B). Top downregulated DEGs in AD NSCs were linked to self-renewal (Nampt, Id1) cell proliferation (e.g., Cst3, Fgfr3, Fabp5), and differentiation (ApoE, Fos, St8sia4) (Figure 3C). Pathways enriched in the NSC cluster compared to all other cell types in the hippocampus included signal transduction, cell proliferation, nervous system development and cell adhesion (Figure 3D). In agreement with DEGs, top downregulated pathways in NSC in NCI and AD were cellular signaling, proliferation, differentiation, migration, regulation of cell death and inflammatory pathways (Figure 3E,F). Similarly to the DEGs pattern, we observed substantial downregulation of peaks in NCI compared to YA, and this effect was further pronounced in AD compared to NCI (Figure 3G,H). Critical signals, such as Sox1, Fgf2, Hes5, Apc, Dicer1-as1 and others had reduced open chromatin pattern in their promotors in NCI and showed further closing of chromatin in MCI and AD (Figure 3G,H, Supplemental Table 10). Examination of overrepresented motifs in these downregulated peaks inferred regulatory programs that are lost relative to the YA. Notably, many transcription factors were enriched in downregulated peaks in NCI relative to YA, with further downregulation in AD, e.g., Rax2, En2, Lbx2. Most of these transcription factors play roles in neurogenesis, brain development (e.g., Rax, En2, Hesx1, Noto, Gbx1, Arx, Uncx), growth and differentiation (lbx2, prrx1, lhx9) and mitochondrial function (gabpa) (Figure 3I). We identified additional motifs, e.g., Tcfl5, Nrf1, which represent additional factors whose functionality was lost specifically in AD. Together, these results indicate that substantial regulatory controls in NSCs are lost with aging, with further exacerbation in MCI and AD.
Alterations in Neuroblast Profile are Pronounced in MCI
In the rodent, neuroblasts are committed to a neuronal fate and give rise to immature neurons1,38. However, there is no information on their profile in the human brain.We identified a small population of neuroblasts. Pathway enrichment in neuroblasts revealed pathways of neuronal differentiation, memory, synaptic vesicle exocytosis, and long-term synaptic potentiation were enriched in neuroblasts (Figure 4A). Next, we asked whether their profile changes with cognitive diagnosis. While alterations in neuroblast transcriptomic profile took place between all four diagnostic groups, substantial differences were observed between NCI and MCI (Figure 4B-F, Supplemental Figure 4, Supplemental Table 6-9). Top DEGs and pathways downregulated in MCI compared to NCI were associated with neuronal differentiation (Figure 4B,D). Additional pathways that were downregulated in AD compared to NCI were related to synaptic plasticity, neuronal differentiation and neurogenesis (Figure 4C,E,F). Interestingly, we detected only few alterations in neuroblast epigenetic profile. Top differential open chromatin peaks that were upregulated in NCI compared to YA, were downregulated in AD, such as in the promoters of Nicotinamide Phosphoribosyltransferase (Nampt), the proliferation and brain development factor Dual Specificity Tyrosine Phosphorylation Regulated Kinase 1A (Dyrk1A). Neural cell adhesion molecule 1 (Ncam1), Recombination Activating 1 factor (Rag1), Smad Family Member 7 (Smad7), Mtor (Mechanistic Target of Rapamycin Kinase) and Bax exhibited alterations in open chromatin peaks as a function of age and diagnosis. The microRNA regulator Dgcr8, and the histone deacetylase component Lysine Demethylase 1A (Kdm1a) and Notch1 showed increased closed chromatin in AD (Figure 4G, Supplemental Table 7). Taken together, our data suggests that neuroblasts are committed to a neuronal differentiation path, but critical signals and pathways of neurotransmitter regulation, synaptic morphology and neurogenesis were compromised with pathology, with substantial alterations taking place in transcription in MCI and further in AD. This suggests that alterations in the profile of neuroblasts are an early biomarker of cognitive deterioration.
Shutdown of transcription machineries in Immature neurons in AD`
In the rodent brain, immature neurons incorporate in the hippocampal circuitry and play a role in hippocampal plasticity. A previous study showed transcriptional dynamics of human immature neurons across the lifespan and showed reduced numbers of immature neurons in AD. However, little is known about their dynamics as a function of cognitive diagnosis. Examination of the profile of immature neurons revealed substantial downregulation of gene expression, including downregulation of most transcripts, peaks and motifs in AD. Specifically, 120 significantly downregulated GOBP pathways in AD compared to NCI (Supplemental Table 11, q <0.05). Pathways enriched in immature neurons were neuronal synaptic plasticity, learning and memory and neurogenesis (Figure 5A). DEG and GOBP analyses revealed substantial downregulation of transcripts and their pathways in AD (Figure 5B,C). Top downregulated pathways were mitochondrial and ribosomal (Figure 5B). A comparison of pathways downregulated in AD compared to MCI in immature neurons revealed downregulated calcium regulation and release, serotonin regulation, cognition, brain function and neurogenesis (q <0.05). Likewise, the gene expression profile of immature neurons in the different diagnoses revealed a vastly different gene profile of immature neurons in AD compared to YA, NCI and MCI. Early alterations in gene expression in immature neurons took place between YA and NCI and included major players in neurogenesis, such as reln, Npy, Calb1,2, Prom1, NeuroD1, Bdnf. Similarly to enriched pathway, the vast majority of differentially expressed genes were downregulated in immature neurons in AD compared to YA and NCI, such as Ptn, S100b, Fgfr2, Dcx, Tgfbr2, Reln (Figure 5C, Supplemental Figure 5). Peak and motif profile per diagnosis revealed severely compromised open chromatin events, including of critical neurogenic genes, such as CamkIIa, Egr1, Efnb2, Fosb, Ngf, Fmr1, E2f3, Kif3a, Vgf in immature neurons in AD (Figure 5D-F). Gene-to-Peak concordance was 9% in immature neurons comparing AD to YA profile, 2% when comparing AD to NCI and 2% in YA compared to NCI. In AD/NCI, most of the concordant peak-gene pairs showed positive correlation and were downregulated in AD (Figure 5G). Gene-peaks of positive concordance play a role in ribosomal structure and function, extracellular vesicular exosome, synaptic density and axogenesis. (Figure 5H). Taken together, our data suggests a considerable cessation of the transcription machineries in immature neurons in AD.
Profile of inhibitory neurons in relation to age and diagnosis
In addition to neurogenesis, our analysis uncovered major alterations in GABAergic neurons in the hippocampal circuitry as a function of age and impairments. Our analysis then identified an acute 4-fold decrease in the number of GABA neurons in NCI, and an additional 2-fold decrease in AD donors (Figure 2A). To gain an insight into the nature of loss of inhibitory neurons, we examined their sub-clusters. In addition to the age- and diagnosis- dependent reduction in total number of inhibitory neurons, we observed that parvalbumin+ (PValb+) neurons were completely lost in NCI (Figure 6A,B), and Vasoactive Intestinal Peptide (VIP)+ and somatostatin (SST)+ were robustly downregulated in NCI compared to YA (Figure 6A,B). Examination of DEGs in subclusters and in PValb+, VIP+ and SST+ neurons in NCI compared to YA revealed downregulation of several signals that play a role in synaptic plasticity. For example, in PValb+ neurons, signals such as metabotropic receptor Grm8, the voltage gated potassium channel Kcnh5, Unc13c predicted to play a role in calmodulin and syntaxin binding activity and the extracellular matrix signal reelin were downregulated (Figure 6C); in SST+ neurons, we observed downregulation of signals, such as Syt10, Sema3C, Kcnh1 and Plxna4 (Figure 6D); in VIP+, downregulation of Gabrd, Sulf1, Epb41, Grik3 (Figure 6E). Examination of the overall profile of inhibitory neurons revealed alterations in transcription as a function of age and diagnosis with marked alterations in AD. DEGs and Pathway enrichment analysis in AD compared to NCI revealed pathways essential for myelin regulation, transmembrane transport, ATP and energy production, mitochondrial function, and translation (Figure 6F-H, Supplemental Figure 6, Supplemental Table 12). Interestingly, there was a large overlap of DEGs in common between Immature and GABAergic neurons, leading to common pathways. Specifically, there were 261 genes that were differentially expressed in AD/NCI in both immature and GABAergic neurons; 245 of them were changing concordantly and 236 were concordantly downregulated. A total of 439 genes were downregulated in Immature neurons, 1446 down in GABA neurons, 236 downregulated in both, out of 32,000 total genes tested in the genome (Odds ratio 29.1, Fisher’s Exact test p-value 8.2e-200). Further, 40 of the downregulated pathways in immature and GABAergic neurons were in common (Odds ratio 424, Fisher’s Exact test p-value 1.7e-64). This may suggest a similar system-level effect between immature and inhibitory neurons in the transition from NCI to AD (Figure 6H, Supplemental Table 13). Interestingly, the majority of peaks in GABA neurons were substantially downregulated in AD compared to other diagnoses, suggesting marked closure of chromatin in these neurons (Figure 6I-K, Supplemental Table 14). Notably, in contrast to DEGs, the number of DE peaks was substantially different between immature and inhibitory neurons. While in the former we observed a large number of differential peaks (41,341 in AD/NCI, 94 up and 41,247 down; 67,532 total in AD/YA, 67 of them were up and 67,465 down), in GABA neurons the effect was smaller. There were 1659 DE peaks in AD/YC (39 up, 1620 down) and only 87 in AD/HA (8 up, 79 down) (Figure 6I,J). Interestingly, of DE peaks in AD/YA, 1463 of the downregulated pathways were in common for immature and inhibitory neurons (Fisher’s Exact test P = 1.4e-232, Supplemental Figure 7 and Supplemental Table 15). Examination of motifs in inhibitory neurons showed 68 strongly enriched (log2 odds ratio >1, FDR<0.01) motifs for downregulated peaks in AD/YC in these neurons, with earliest alterations in MCI compared to YA (Figure 6K). Together, our data suggests an age-dependent loss of inhibitory neurons in the hippocampus, characterized, in part, by loss of synaptic plasticity signalling, a set of processes led by transcription, accompanied by some chromatic closure in MCI and AD.
Neurogenic cell type communication with the cellular environment
To start to address a putative interaction of neurogenesis with their cellular niche in the human brain, we attempted to predict cell interaction by examining ligand-receptor co-expression using CellChat 39 and NeuronChat 40 . The strongest interaction of neurogenesis was with oligodendrocyte precursor cells (OPCs) and inhibitory neurons (Figure 7A,B). Interaction analysis showed that NSCs, neuroblasts and immature neurons are predicted to communicate with all neighboring cells in the DG via cell adhesion molecules, ligand-receptor interaction, neurotransmitter secretion, synaptic adhesion molecules and the secretion of neuropeptides (Supplemental Tables 16,17). For example, immature neurons and neuroblasts secrete glutamate, that binds GRIN2D receptors expressed in inhibitory neurons and astrocytes (Figure 7C,D). Similarly, several cell types, including neuroblasts and inhibitory neurons secrete NRXN1,3 which binds NLGN2 receptors in immature and CA neurons (Figure 7E,F). These pathways play critical roles in synaptic plasticity and are implicated in cognitive deficits and AD dementia 41-44 . These analyses further inferred ligand-receptor pathways that may play a role in a decline in cell-cell interaction as a function of pathology in immature neurons, as well as ligands and receptors that may be exclusively expressed in immature neurons (Supplemental Figure 8, Supplemental Tables 16,17). Specifically, cross reference of DEGs to the interactions from CellChat and NeuronChat revealed that there were no significant alterations in cell-cell interactions because of altered ligands secreted by immature neurons in NCI compared to YA(Supplemental Tables 16,17). However, several ligand-receptor pathways led a decline in cell-cell interaction as a function of pathology in immature neurons. Particularly, Efna5,Ptn, Lama2, Sema5a,6D ligands secreted by immature neurons. These ligands bind receptors expressed by several cell types in the hippocampus (Supplemental Figure 8A-F). This analysis further revealed ligands that were exclusively expressed in immature neurons. Unique ligands included Pdgfd, Postn, Efnb3, L1cam, Lrrc4, Bmp7, Cntn2, Ncam1, Nectin3 (Supplemental Figure 8G-S). Interestingly, we found high gene-peak concordance for Ephb6, 1, Epha4, Efnb2,3, Oprm1, Oprd1 and Pdyn, validating a concordance of open chromatin regions and transcription factors that could regulate expression of these ligands and receptors. Total cell-cell interaction in relation to diagnosis revealed that in most cell types in the hippocampus, the number of ligand and receptor interactions in YA was greater compared to NCI (Figure 7G,J). In contrast, a marked reduction in ligand - receptor interactions takes place in MCI compared to YA and in AD compared to NCI (Figure 7G,J). The number of differentially expressed ligands or receptors in immature neurons as well as total interactions in YC was largely upregulated compared to NCI (Figure 7H,I,K,L). In contrast, interactions were largely downregulated in AD compared to the other diagnoses (Figure 7H,I,K,L). Neuron-specific ligand-receptor analysis revealed that most interactions were downregulated in immature neurons in MCI compared to YA, suggesting that reduced interaction precedes the onset of AD. Interestingly, the total number of interactions to or from each individual cell type by neuronal ligands was lower in selected cell types, i.e., mGC, immature neurons, GABA neurons and CA neurons, in YA compared to NCI (Figure 7M). Interactions were further substantially reduced in all cell types in AD compared to YA (Figure 7M-O). The number of interactions to or from each individual cell type by neuronal receptors was largely reduced in MCI/YA and AD/MCI (Figure 7P,R).