Nintedanib is an intracellular inhibitor that targets multiple tyrosine kinases and hereby inhibits fundamental processes in the pathogenesis of fibrosis. Although proven to be effective in IPF and Ssc-related ILD, the efficacy and tolerability of nintedanib in other connective-tissue-disease-related ILD (CTD-ILD), IIM-ILD in particular, has never been clarified. To date, this is the first clinical research focusing on nintedanib therapy in IIM-ILD patients. And nintedanib was found effective in reducing incidence of RP-ILD and improving survival in these patients. However, patients receiving nintedanib therapy did not suffer from less complication of pulmonary infection or receive more simplified immunosuppressive regimen as we expected. Tolerability of nintedanib therapy was as well evaluated by recording and discussing the adverse events, dosage reduction and discontinuation of the therapy.
Nintedanib has already been proved of therapeutic value in reducing lung function decline and acute exacerbation of idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (AE-IPF) in IPF patients. The previous TOMORROW trial, INPULSIS-1 and INPULSIS-2 trials demonstrated that nintedanib promisingly reduced the annual rate of decline in FVC [16, 17]. The therapeutic effect of nintedanib remain consistent irrespective of age, sex, ethnicity and baseline percent-predicted forced vital capacity (FVC%) [28, 29]. And the efficacy in slowing lung function decline could last over 3 years [30]. Similar results were also reported in several real-world experience across Europe during the Compassionate Use Programs (CUPs) or after license [31–33]. In addition, the TOMORROW trial and INPULSIS-2 trial also demonstrated that nintedanib played a protective role in preventing AE-IPF [34]. In INPULSIS-2 trial, nintedanib significantly increased the time to the first acute exacerbation. Meanwhile the incidence of acute exacerbation was reduced in TOMORROW trial. The following INPULSIS-ON trial also suggested that nintedanib’s therapeutic effect in reducing occurrence of acute exacerbation persisted beyond 3 years. In in SENSCIS trial, nintedanib was identified to decrease FVC decline in Ssc-ILD, nevertheless, its effect on RP-ILD was not probed into [18]. The recently completed INBUILD trial demonstrated the consistent effect of nintedanib on reducing FVC decline in different ILD subgroups, irrespective of the underlying ILD diagnosis [20]. In our study, nintedanib was found to reduce the incidence of the fatal RP-ILD in IIM-ILD patients, which for the first time initially demonstrated the therapeutic value of nintedanib in IIM-ILD regardless of the retrospective nature and lack of follow-up lung function testing. In the future, large-cohort,prospective, multicenter research concerning IIM-ILD is demanded to verify the role of nintedanib in decreasing incidence of RP-ILD, as well as explore its effect in lung function decline, etc.
In addition to decreasing the incidence of RP-ILD in follow-up, nintedanib was also observed to benefit the survival of IIM-ILD patients. Similar finding in IPF patients was also reported in an Italian multicenter study with a favorable 1-year survival of 79% [35]. On the one hand, RP-ILD has been proven to be a risk factor for death in IIM-ILD patients [10, 11]. Nintedanib might improve IIM patients’ survival by reducing the incidence of RP-ILD. On the other hand, nintedanib was still found to play a protective role in survival after adjusting for RP-ILD, etc., which led us to consider the possible therapeutic value of nintedanib beyond ILD. In preclinical models of systemic sclerosis, nintedanib was confirmed to alleviate skin fibrosis by decreasing of dermal thickness, myofibroblast counts and hydroxyproline content [36]. However, no clinical benefit of nintedanib was identified for extra-pulmonary manifestations of systemic sclerosis in SENSCIS trial [18]. In terms of IIM, preceding studies proposed the essential role of tyrosine kinase in type I IFN signaling in pathogenesis of DM [37]. As a tyrosine kinase inhibitor [38], the effect of nintedanib on disease activity, muscular or extra-muscular involvements as well as pathogenesis of IIM, DM in particular, is worth exploration in the future.
During the course of nintedanib therapy, adverse events were inevitable in most patients and might impede the therapeutic regimen by dosage reduction or discontinuation of therapy. In our study, 63.6% of IIM-ILD patients receiving nintedanib therapy suffered from adverse events. Almost half of nintedanib-treated patients finally received reduced dosage of nintedanib or discontinued the therapy. The incidence of adverse events was much lower than those (> 90%) reported in preceding clinical trials possibly owing to exclusion of IPF progression, upper respiratory tract infection, etc. from adverse events [16–18]. Diarrhea was the most common adverse event in IIM-ILD patients, which resembled the reports from series of clinical trials and real-world analyses [16–18, 20, 31–33, 39]. Besides, liver function monitoring and timely liver-protected medication should be emphasized in IIM-ILD patients since it was identified as the major direct contributor to dosage reduction or discontinuation due to adverse event.
MSAs and MAAs are two main subtypes of antibodies in IIM patients. They were valuable in the field of diagnosis and evaluation. In preceding studies, anti-MDA5 antibody was found to be correlated with ILD, RP-ILD as well as death in DM or ADM patients [40–42]. However, its role in ILD and progression of ILD remained disputable [43]. In this study, anti-MDA5 antibody was recognized as a risk factor for death in IIM-ILD patients. Nevertheless, no correlation was identified between anti-MDA5 antibody and RP-ILD, which indicated the unreliable role of anti-MDA5 antibody in predicting progression of ILD. In addition, anti PM-Scl75 antibody, which was previously taken as an inconspicuous MSA indicating risk of overlapping with systemic sclerosis, was found to be associated with RP-ILD in IIM-ILD patients. Lorenzo, etc. proposed that anti-PM-Scl-positive patients tended to exhibit more extra-muscular features like ILD, esophageal reflux disease, etc. in comparison with other myositis patients [44]. Preceding evidence on its linkage with RP-ILD was not sufficient. In a French multicenter study, only 17% of myositis patients with anti-PM-Scl antibody suffered from deterioration of ILD [45]. In contrast, Lega and his colleagues found that ILD worsened in 4 out of 9 anti-PM-Scl-positive patients [46]. This is the first study suggesting the predicting role of anti-PM-Scl75 antibody in RP-ILD among IIM-ILD patients. In the future, larger cohort study is demanded to verify our finding.
Elevated MYOACT score, which reflected higher disease activity in IIM patients, was found to be correlated with RP-ILD and death. As a core set measure for IIM patients, MYOACT score work as an overall assessment of IIM disease activity by taking muscular and various extra-muscular manifestations into consideration. It has been demonstrated to predict outcome of IIM patients and reflect inflammatory level [47, 48]. Meanwhile RP-ILD was also found to be associated with cytokines like tumor necrosis factor, etc [49]. The partially overlapped pathological mechanism might make MYOACT score a satisfying predictor for RP-ILD in IIM-ILD patients.
The most significant limitations of this study were the retrospective and observational nature as well as the small sample size. Due to the initial lack of follow-up lung function testing and recent impact of COVID-19 pandemic, we failed to clarify the effect of nintedanib on lung function decline. Baseline FVC%, DLCO%, age, immunosuppressive therapy, etc. were not controlled for inclusion because of the limited number of IIM-ILD patients receiving nintedanib therapy. No placebo was given to patients in the control group. Alterations of life quality, MYOACT score, muscle strength, etc. after nintedanib therapy were not recorded. Last but not least, underestimation of RP-ILD might occur in patients under conventional medications owing to initial lack of mandatory management. In spite of all the limitations, we intended to initially figure out the therapeutic value of nintedanib in IIM-ILD, and shed some light on the future therapeutic landscape of CTD-ILD.