Schizophrenia is a mental illness with cognitive deficits that are a core feature on the disease, and characterized by dysfunction in the dopamine system. Therefore, it is relevant to mention that the NR4A2 gene has been considered as a candidate gene for schizophrenia due to its relevant role in the dopamine system.
The NR4A2 (NURR1) transcription factor regulates the expression of important genes in the development and phenotype of dopaminergic neurons [1, 2, 50]. In addition, it participates in the modulation of metabolic, inflammatory, and cognitive processes [23, 24, 51–54]. Alteration in the NR4A2 gene has been proposed as animal model of schizophrenia [18, 19]. Furthermore, different animal models and clinical studies support the importance of the NR4A2 gene in cognitive processes [17, 20, 21]. In particular, several studies support the important role of NR4A2 in memory [16, 18, 21–24]. Various studies have considered this gene as a potential therapeutic target and biomarker in neurological and psychiatric disorders [55–58].
It is important to mention that this is the first study to analyze the association of two genetic variants of the NR4A2 gene (rs34884856 in promoter and rs35479735 in intron 6) and NR4A2 mRNA expression with working memory deficits in schizophrenia.
Genetic association study between NR4A2 variants and schizophrenia
This study did not identify any association between the genetic variants analyzed and the risk of schizophrenia. Genetic association studies of NR4A2 variants with this mental disorder in different populations have produced inconclusive and controversial results [27–30, 32, 59]. This could be due to the heterogeneity of the disease diagnosis, the different populations included, and the sample sizes analyzed in different studies. The two genetic variants analyzed in this study have been associated with other neurological, and psychiatric disorders and addiction, which are diseases with altered dopamine function. In particular, the rs35479735 intronic variant has been associated with Parkinson’s disease in Asian, Caucasian, and Mexican populations [33–35]. In addition, the rs34884856 promoter variant has been associated with alcohol dependence in people with Mexican ancestry [36]. It should be highlighted that the genotypic frequencies observed in our study are similar to those identified in Asian populations and different from those reported for Caucasian populations in diseases associated with dopamine dysfunction such as schizophrenia [29, 33, 34].
Analysis of NR4A2 mRNA peripheral expression levels between schizophrenia patients and the control group as well as with NR4A2 genetic variants
In contrast to other studies [13, 37, 38] where a decreased mRNA expression level of NR4A2 was identified in brain tissue (DLPFC) of schizophrenia patients, our study showed no significant differences in such expression levels in the mRNA obtained from peripheral blood. It should be noted, however, that the current study analyzed a different type of biological sample (blood vs cerebral cortex tissue). It has been reported that peripheral expression of this gene was found to be significantly decreased in Parkinson’s disease (PD), which is a disease associated mainly with the degeneration of dopaminergic neurons, as well as with aging in different populations [32, 35, 60, 61]. In addition, we did not find an influence of the genetic variants analyzed on the expression levels of the NR4A2 gene in schizophrenia patients as seen in PD patients [35]. In this neurodegenerative disease it has been previously reported that the levels of expression of the NR4A2 gene were decreased in 3C homozygous compared to the other genotypes of the rs34884856 promoter variant [35].
Association between auditory working memory performance and the rs34884856 promoter variant
Working memory is one of the most widely researched cognitive functions as a cognitive endophenotype of schizophrenia given that it reflects prefrontal cortex alterations [62, 63]. Working memory refers to the mechanisms or processes involved in the control, regulation, and keeping of relevant information active for the execution of complex cognitive tasks [64]. This cognitive function is defined as a system for both temporal storage and manipulation of information, with it participating in key cognitive processes, such as language comprehension, reading, and reasoning [65].
In the present study, an association between the rs34884856 promoter variant of the NR4A2 gene and auditory working memory in schizophrenia patients was identified. The analysis for the recessive model of this variant (3C/3C versus “3C/2C + 2C/2C”) showed significant differences in the scores for BDS; 3C homozygous patients were lower when compared to 2C allele carriers (Table 3, p = 0.027). This is supported by a study that showed the association of genetic variants of this gene with sustained attention in schizophrenia patients in a Caucasian population [31]. Nevertheless, this association was not identified in the control group. However, both the genetic variants analyzed and the cognitive functions evaluated in that previously study are different from those analyzed in our study. It is noteworthy that in our study the relationship between the promoter variant and the working memory functions identified in schizophrenia patients were different from the control group for the BDS task.
Working memory subtests can be classified as verbal and nonverbal. In this classification, the left side of DLPFC is more related to verbal tests and the right side of DLPFC is more related to visual spatial tests. Information input divides working memory into auditory (for instance, Backward Digit Span) and visual spatial. It has been noted that the prefrontal cortex regions involved in simple information storage are different from the regions involved in actively manipulating stored information [66].
The difference found between patients and control group regarding the promoter variant can be related to the way in which information is received for processing, and to the affected brain regions in patients. For example, working memory subtests can be classified as verbal and nonverbal. In this classification, the left side of DLPFC is more related to verbal tests and the right side of DLPFC is more related to visual spatial tests. Information input divides working memory into auditory (for instance, BDS) and visual spatial. It has been noted that the prefrontal cortex regions involved in simple information storage are different from the regions involved in actively manipulating stored information [66]. In addition, the left hemisphere shows greater pathological alterations in schizophrenia compared to the right hemisphere [67].
Our findings are consistent with studies evaluating other genetic variants that have shown these inconsistencies related to the effects of the allele between different tests and pathological conditions. One of the most widely researched variants demonstrating this effect is the BDNF genetic variant (Val66met) [68, 69]. In this case, the Met allele has a differential effect between patients and controls regarding the same cognitive function.
In addition, the importance of the NR4A2 gene in relation with metabolism and neuroprotection of dopaminergic neurons allows us to understand the association identified with cognitive endophenotypes of a working memory construct. In order to provide support for the aforementioned, various studies with genes related to dopaminergic metabolism have showed its association with cognitive endophenotypes [70].
Association between cognitive functions and expression levels of the NR4A2 gene
This is the first study to identify a positive correlation between NR4A2 gene expression levels and working memory function in schizophrenia patients. Our results are consistent with previous studies that show that the NR4A2 gene dosage is significantly related to cognitive function in animal models of schizophrenia [18, 19]. The association of NR4A2 deficiency and reduction in performance on cognitive tasks has been reported for Alzheimer´s disease and attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder animal models [17, 20], as well as with reports of its important role in diverse memory tasks in preclinical studies [16, 21–24]. NR4A2 is also involved in neurodevelopmental disorders and cognitive deficits as reported in clinical trials [14, 15].
We identified a significant positive correlation of NR4A2 mRNA expression levels with performance on the BDS task in 3C/3C patients (rs34884856 promoter variant). The association between NR4A2 mRNA expression and better cognitive performance was found in this task of working memory.
In particular, the analysis on the BDS task demonstrated a key association when adjusting variables that affect cognition, such as age, gender, and education level. Our main result was the association of performance on the BDS with the rs34884856 promoter variant and the expression levels of the NR4A2 gene in schizophrenia patients. For instance, the BDS task allows the evaluation of alterations in auditory working memory, which is related to the left DLPFC.
Our results are consistent with the relationship between cognitive deficits in schizophrenia and dysfunction in different brain regions related to cortex, such as the DLPFC, medial prefrontal cortex, and visual cortex [63]. Therefore, a decrease in dopaminergic neurotransmission in those brain regions could be related to the cognitive deficits in this psychiatric disorder, in particular, the decrease in the NR4A2 gene in the left DLPFC (area involved in working memory, mainly auditory) in schizophrenia patients.
One of the main limitations of the present study was the sample size for cognitive analysis. However, no significant differences concerning characteristics that could affect cognitive function were found between the different genotypic groups in either patients or controls. In addition, the functional effect of the rs34884856 promoter variant of the NR4A2 gene has not yet been described. Therefore, this genetic variant could be in linkage disequilibrium with another polymorphism that has a functional effect on the expression levels of this gene and thus, on cognitive function.