Thermophilic Diversity Analysis
The analysis of the sequences of the Tecozautla geyser allowed the identification of 30 bacterial phyla and only 2 archaea, 70 classes, 79 orders, 72 families, and 44 genera. An important observation is that bacteria without taxonomic assignment with high percentages in abundance were found in the 4 samples analyzed, some authors have described similar results; the lack of taxonomic assignment can be attributed to the fact that their identification has not been possible due to the difficulty of their isolation preventing identification and characterization. It was observed that the phylum Armatimonadetes was the most abundant in the GD sample. The Chthonomonadetes class is part of this phylum which is present in the GD sample with ~ 0.02 % of the total sequences, the only cultivated strain is Chthonomonas calidirosea, which can grow in an interval of 50–73°C, pH 4.5–5.8 and 2 % NaCl [12]. The OS-L class, which corresponds to unidentified microorganisms, was also found in samples GA, GC, and GD, this class was found in Octopus Springs in Yellowstone National Park [13]. The species Fimbriimonas ginsengisoli, which belongs to the class Fimbriimonadia, can indirectly provide information about the class. It is a strict anaerobic mesophilic microorganism (https://www.genome.jp/Tools-bin/taxsummary).
The phylum Armatimonadetes is a moderately abundant and phylogenetically diverse bacterial group, little studied and phylogenetically associated with Chloroflexi [12]. Three cultured individuals are known, two previously mentioned and Armatimonas rosea. The candidate phylum OP10 (now Armatimonadetes) was first described in the ecology study of Obsidian Pool, a geothermal hot spring in Yellowstone National Park [12].
Armatimonadetes have been identified in different areas of the world as in Tibetan hot springs (32–86°C, pH 3.0-9.5) [14], in Sungai Klah hot springs, Malaysia (50–110°C, pH 7.0–9.0) [15], in sediments and water from Great Boiling Spring, United States (62–82°C, pH 6.63–7.40) [16].
The phylum Cyanobacteria is one of the most abundant in most of the known microbial mats of thermal and non-thermal waters, participating in the fixation of carbon and nitrogen [17]. They have been identified in the hot springs of Garga, Russia, with temperatures of 70°C, 55°C, and 45°C; pH 8.0–9.0, with abundances ranging from ~ 10 to 60 %, in the 7 types of microbial mats studied [18]. Likewise, the phylum was found in abundances of 1.2–36.6 %, in all the samples of the microbial mats of the Camargo wetlands (Rhone Delta, southern France) that present temperatures of 13.5–18°C, and in non-thermal waters [19]. In the same way, they have been detected in the thermal areas of the Pakistanis Himalayas in conditions of 60–95°C with a pH of 6.2–9.4 [20], and in El Coquito, located in the Colombian Andes that present temperatures of 29°C in the source and pH of 2.7 [21]. The Cyanobacteria class was found in Ghats, India, with abundances of 96.42 % and 87.35 % of the total classes for the AT (58°C, pH 8.56) and TP (48°C, pH 8.76) samples [22].
From the analysis of the phylum Cyanobacteria that was detected in the samples from the Tecozautla geyser, the most studied genera are Gloeobacter, which contains two species that are Gloeobacter violaceus and Gloeobacter kilaueensis, the latter isolated in a cave near the lava caldera of the volcano Kilauea in Hawaii. Both are non-thylakoidal and carry out oxygenic photosynthesis [23].
Leptolyngbya is one of the most common and frequent filamentous cyanobacterial genera in thermal environments, occurring in a wide range of terrestrial, aquatic, and extreme environments and equally distributed in Mexico [24]. Finally, the genus Pseudanabaena is anoxygenic photoautotrophic thermophilic cyanobacterium, also found in Yellowstone National Park, and is one of the main responsible for the formation of microbial mats in Chocolate Pool to 52°C, in addition to having been found in geysers in areas that exceed 60°C, as well as in the Amazon River at ~ 30°C, which shows that it can grow at different temperature ranges and habitats [23]. An important point to note about filamentous cyanobacteria is that they are encapsulated by exopolysaccharides, making them difficult to lyse and nucleic acids can be trapped, making them inaccessible for polymerase chain reaction and sequencing [25].
The phylum Chloroflexi has been found in the Garga hot spring microbial mats, where the incidence of Chloroflexi and Chlorobi did not represent > 10 % of the total number of sequences in the Ga2-verh and Ga3-sred samples [26]. The phylum Chloroflexi is one of the most found in thermal environments in the world, the presence of Chloroflexi predominates in microbial mats with temperatures of 53–65°C and slightly alkaline pH (7.75–7.91), similar to the samples of the Tecozautla geyser [27]. They have also been identified in microbial mats (66°C, pH ∼ 6.5), with relative abundances of ~ 18 to 50 % [28], which are similar to the percentages found in the geyser understudy for Cyanobacteria and Chloroflexi. Chloroflexi was identified in microbial mats from hot springs in Costa Rica, constituting 93 % of all readings, the conditions of the sample area were 37–60°C and pH 6.1–7.5 [29]. Likewise, it is known that the phylum Chloroflexi is very widespread in microbial mats of hot springs in Japan [30], Yellowstone (USA) [31], Kamchatka, Thailand, Tibet [23], and in the Andes [32].
The phylum Chloroflexi currently comprises eight subgroups at the class level: Chloroflexia, Anaerolineae, Ardenticatenia, Caldilineae, Dehalococcoidia, Ktedenobacteria, Thermoflexia, and Thermomicrobia, which mainly contain chlorophotrophic and non-phototrophic filamentous bacteria [33]. Furthermore, unidentified classes of bacteria are found in this phylum [34].
The class Chloroflexia has two orders, Herpetosiphonales and Chloroflexales, of the latter they are divided into two families: Roseiflexineae and Chloroflexineae (https://www.genome.jp/tools-bin/taxsummary), although previously they were known as green bacteria without sulfur. Chloroflexal chlorophotrophic organisms are now known as filamentous anoxygenic phototrophs (FAP). They are characterized by their multicellular, filamentous morphology, with lengths of several hundred µm, and an anoxygenic photoheterotrophic/photomyxotrophic lifestyle [30, 33, 34].
The abundances of the two most common chlorophotrophs of Chloroflexi (Roseiflexus castenholzii and Chloroflexus spp.) vary with temperature. At temperatures lower than 60°C, Roseiflexus spp. are more abundant, but when temperatures are higher, Chloroflexus spp. they are predominant at ~ 70°C [30]. In the Tecozautla geyser, Hidalgo, the genera with the highest relative abundance were Roseiflexus and Chloroflexus. The first is a photosynthetic, filamentous, thermophilic bacterium lacking chlorosomes, with a single cultured species Roseiflexus castenholzii with optimal growth temperature of 45–55°C and pH 7.5–8 [30]. The second genus contains only two species: Chloroflexus aurantiacus and Chloroflexus aggregans, both with optimal growth temperatures of 55°C, the first with a growth limit of 70°C and the second of 60°C, they are generally found in neutral alkaline hot springs [35]. Chloroflexus are photoheterotrophic and chemoheterotrophic, they inhabit microbial mats of thermal waters together with cyanobacteria, their growth can occur at temperatures of 30 to 70°C. Furthermore, they are facultative bacteria capable of growing photoheterotrophically under anaerobic and chemoheterotrophic conditions under aerobic conditions [33, 35].
The phylum Deinococcus-Thermus is considered a group of microorganisms abundant in hot springs [21, 36]. With a presence in hot springs and microbial mats in Tibet (China), Sichuan (China), Mushroom Spring and Calcite Springs, YNP (USA), Siloam (South Africa), Bulgaria (Eastern Europe), Chile (South America) [14, 28]. The phylum Deinococcus-Thermus includes the class Deinococci and this is currently divided into the orders Deinococcales and Thermales. The first is made up of the Deinococcus, Deinobacterium, and Truepera genera. All members of Deinococcus are radioresistant, with two known thermophiles Deinococcus geothermalis and Deinococcus murrayi [36]. In the case of Truepera, the only cultivated species is Truepera radiovictrix resistant to ionizing radiation with optimal growth at pH 7.5–9.5 up to pH 11.2, with the ability to grow in multiple extreme conditions in alkaline, moderately saline, and high-temperature habitats [37]. The Thermales order encompasses five genera (Thermus, Meiothermus, Marinithermus, Oceanithermus, and Vulcanithermus). Cultured representatives of Thermus are thermophilic and hyperthermophilic. The members of Thermales have recovered from a large set of natural and man-made thermal environments. These bacteria and their cellular components are of biotechnological interest with possible applications in bioremediation or molecular biology, for example, thermostable enzymes [38]. Their ecological importance stands out in that they play an important role in the carbon, nitrogen, and sulfur cycles, such as Thermus oshimai, Thermus thermophilus [39], or as Thermus scotoductus with oxidizing mixotrophic characteristics of sulfur [40]. In the case of the Tecozautla geyser, only the genera Thermus and Meiothermus were found.
Regarding the phylum Proteobacteria, its presence has been reported in habitats with temperatures of 29–35°C and pH 3.5–6.5, with relative abundances of 60 % which decreases significantly at 68°C (pH 6.9) with < 10 % [32]. They have also been found in microbial mats, sediments, and hot springs in Eritrea (Africa) with relative abundances of 6.2 to 82.3 %, with conditions of temperatures of 44 to 110°C and pH of 6.97 to 7.54 [41], which allows elucidating that Proteobacteria inhabit a wide spectrum of environmental conditions. The diversity of Proteobacteria is based on the classes, that is, Alpha, Beta, Epsilon, and Gamma, a habitat with the presence of all four classes is an indication of the high diversity of this phylum, as was the case of the Tecozautla geyser that shares the same diversity with the thermal devil's eye [40]. The phylum Proteobacteria is home to the largest variety of bacteria in all environments in the world, including phototrophic and anoxygenic bacteria that predominate in many geothermal environments. They are an important part of ecosystems because they participate in the sulfur and carbon cycle such as purple sulfur bacteria (PSB), type I methanotrophs, which belong to Gammaproteobacteria, purple sulfur-free bacteria (PNSB) that belong to Betaproteobacteria and Alphaproteobacteria, in addition to type II methanotrophs. Sulfate-reducing bacteria (SRB) belong to Deltaproteobacteria, being the main components in environments related to geothermal, alkaline lakes, and saline environments [20, 25].
The PSBs belong to the Chromatiales order in the Gammaroteobacteria and within the Chromatiales the PSBs are separated into the Chromatiaceae and Ectothiorhodospiraceae families. All PSB species and their families can perform anoxygenic photosynthesis under anoxic conditions and fix CO2 by the Rubisco enzyme and the Calvin-Benson-Bassham cycle. PSBs are mesophilic organisms that can also photo-assimilate small organic molecules or grow heterotrophically in the dark. Under favorable conditions, they have the ability to reduce N2 to ammonia. In addition to converting sulfur into less toxic compounds such as sulfate [33]. Nitrogen fixation is widely distributed among PNSB. Many of them can use sulfur as an electron donor, but can generally only tolerate low sulfur concentrations < 0.5 mM. Like PSBs, PNSBs are ubiquitously found in mesophilic, circumferential neutral aquatic, or terrestrial environments. Exceptions occur, some prefer acidic, alkaline, or hypersaline conditions. Isolates of thermophilic microorganisms with growth > 50°C are unknown; only mildly thermophilic PNSB species have been isolated (Blastochloris sp. and Rhodocista sp.) which grow up to 47°C, these bacteria were identified in slightly alkaline hot springs [33]. The third physiological group of chlorophotrophic proteobacteria is the aerobic anoxygenic purple bacteria (AAPB), with species belonging to the α, β, and γ proteobacteria. Unlike the other two groups, AAPBs require oxygen and organic molecules for their growth. They lack the ability to use CO2 as their primary carbon source. However, they can obtain up to ~ 15 % of their cellular carbon by anaplerotic CO2 fixation reactions [33]. AAPBs are found in freshwater and marine aquatic environments, as well as in soil crusts and microbial mats from hot springs. They have recently been found in the microbial mats of Octopus Springs and Mushroom springs as well as in the Tecozautla geyser.
Another phylum found in the Tecozautla geyser was the Bacteroidetes phylum. This phylum is a large group of anaerobic and gram-negative chemoganotrophic organisms that do not form endospores and are not mobile by sliding, with wide distribution in the environment [42], with presence in water samples, wet sediments, and microbial mats from hot springs from Eritrea, Ethiopia with abundances of 2.7 to 8.4 % and with growth conditions of 49.5°C to 100°C and pH of 6.97 to 7.54 [41]. They have also been detected in Himalayan hot springs with relative abundances of 74.28 % at temperatures of 60–80°C and pH 8.0-8.5 [43]. Which suggests high adaptability to alkalo-thermophilic conditions.
Alpha diversity analysis
Studies based on the sequencing of 16S rRNA genes have facilitated the understanding of microbial diversity, knowing its composition, function, and dynamics. Although there is no general agreement on which diversity index is the best, in general, it is necessary to use a series of them for greater accuracy [47]. In Fig. 3A, the behavior of the accumulation curves of the 4 samples of the Tecozautla geyser is observed, which describe the relationship that exists between the number of OTUs observed and the sampling effort, the graph provides information on the total of the diversity in the sampled community, to know if the number of sequences obtained represent a significant fraction of the diversity of the community, showing that when the curve has an asymptote, the greatest diversity and the maximum sampling effort have been identified [48].
In the 4 samples of the geyser differences are observed between them, the GD sample of light blue color, presented the greatest diversity, because it does not show a defined asymptote. In the remaining samples a similar behavior is observed among themselves and they follow an asymptotic trend, which suggests that the greatest amount of diversity possible was identified and the sampling effort was adequate as described [48]. The Good coverange graph (Fig. 3B) measures how well the sampling was carried out in an environment and indicates the percentage of individuals sampled in a microbial community, where values greater than 0.9%, evidence that the sequencing effort is sufficient to represent the largest number of species [49]. The result observed in Fig. 3B therefore showed that the sequencing effort was sufficient to represent the largest number of species.
The Chao1 index (richness) (Fig. 3C) estimates the abundance of individuals in a sample, in the so-called species accumulation curve, where the x-axis is the number of individuals sampled or the sampling units examined, which in this case is the sequencing depth, and the y-axis is the number of species observed. The Chao1 index is calculated taking into account the total number of species, as well as the number of rare species and those found twice in the sample.
The results for the four samples of the geyser show different behaviors among themselves, this is due to the fact that in the GD sample (microbial mat-sediments) a greater number of individuals is estimated, followed by the GA sample (salts), and the two Microbial mats from the GB and GC samples, which have similar behavior to each other, with a smaller number of individuals.
The Shannon-Weiner index (diversity) (Fig. 3D) is defined as the estimator of species richness and uniformity. Typical values are generally between 1.5 and 3.5 in most ecological studies, and the index is rarely greater than 4 [47, 50]. The results reflect that the GD (microbial mat-sediments) and GC (microbial mat II) samples have greater diversity because both exceed the value of 3.5, but the GD sample is even more abundant because it is ~ 5, in addition to that values greater than 4 have greater diversity and are not so common. In the case of the GA and GB samples, they have values around 3 which indicates that they have an average diversity.
The Simpson metric also called dominance index (Fig. 3E), which derives from the probability theory, allows quantifying the diversity of habitat, reflects the probability of finding two individuals belonging to the same species in two successive extractions, that is, the closer the value of this index is to 1, there is a greater possibility of the dominance of a species, and the closer it is to the value of zero, the greater the biodiversity of a habitat. This index gives a higher weight to common or similar species and underestimates rare species [51]. Therefore, in the GB sample, there is a greater probability of predominance of a particular species, followed by the GD sample and finally, the GA and GC samples presented similar percentages.