Temporal pattern of IgG response in convalescent COVID-19 patients.
Within a month from the first positive nasopharyngeal swab, SARS-CoV-2 IgG was detected in 78 (70.3%) of 111 recovering COVID-19 patients, 6 (5.4%) patients had intermediate IgG results, and 27 (24.3%) patients were found to be negative for SARS-CoV-2 IgG
Figure 1 presents the rate of SARS-CoV-2 IgG detection by the time from diagnosis, ranging from 47.1% to 93.8% among patients tested during the first and fourth week form diagnosis, respectively (p=0.006). Five of six intermediate IgG results were obtained in patients tested during the second week (days 8-14), with the greatest antibody detection shift noticed between the second and third week post diagnosis. The mean time from diagnosis was significantly longer for patients with positive SARS-CoV-2 IgG (15.6 ± 6.0 vs. 11.0 ± 4.9 days in IgG negative patients; p<0.001), as also demonstrated for the mean time from symptoms onset (21.3 ± 8.9 vs. 13.6 ± 8.3 days; p<0.001). The longest time from symptoms onset during which a patient remained IgG negative was 44 days, while the shortest time from symptoms onset to IgG positivity was 8 days.
Comparison of demographic, clinical, and laboratory features between IgG-positive and IgG-negative patients.
Comparison of IgG-positive and IgG-negative patients revealed no significant differences in demographic characteristics and in the presence of underlying medical conditions (Table 1). Smoking and hypertension were the most common comorbidities in both groups. Only three patients had underlying immunosuppression (kidney transplantation, multiple sclerosis, and chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy).
Table 1: Comparison of demographic and clinical characteristics between SARS-CoV-2 IgG-positive and IgG-negative patients
Characteristic
|
N (%) of patients a
|
P value
|
All Patients
(n=111)
|
Antibody-positive
(n=78)
|
Antibody-negative
(n=27)
|
Age group
|
|
|
|
|
<30
|
36 (32.4)
|
22 (28.2)
|
9 (33.3)
|
0.63
|
30 – 39
|
21 (18.9)
|
15 (19.2)
|
6 (22.2)
|
40 – 49
|
12 (10.8)
|
8 (10.3)
|
4 (14.8)
|
50 – 59
|
16 (14.4)
|
12 (15.4)
|
3 (11.1)
|
60 – 69
|
18 (16.2)
|
15 (19.2)
|
3 (11.1)
|
70 – 79
|
7 (6.3)
|
6 (7.7)
|
1 (3.7)
|
≥ 80
|
1 (0.9)
|
0 (0.0)
|
1 (3.7)
|
Sex
|
|
|
|
|
Male
|
76 (68.5)
|
57 (73.1)
|
18 (66.7)
|
0.53
|
Female
|
35 (31.5)
|
21 (26.9)
|
9 (33.3)
|
Underlying medical conditions
|
|
|
|
|
Any
|
41 (36.9)
|
28 (35.9)
|
1 1 (40.7)
|
0.65
|
Smoking
|
17 (15.3)
|
12 (15.4)
|
4 (14.8)
|
1.0
|
Diabetes mellitus
|
7 (6.3)
|
6 (7.7)
|
1 (3.7)
|
0.67
|
Hypertension
|
14 (12.6)
|
9 (11.5)
|
5 (18.5)
|
0.35
|
Congestive heart failure
|
1 (0.9)
|
1 (1.3)
|
0 (0.0)
|
1.0
|
Ischemic heart disease
|
6 (5.4)
|
4 (5.1)
|
2 (7.4)
|
0.65
|
Lung disease
|
5 (4.5)
|
2 (2.6)
|
2 (7.4)
|
0.27
|
Chronic kidney disease
|
2 (1.8)
|
2 (2.6)
|
0 (0.0)
|
1.0
|
Immunosuppression
|
3 (2.7)
|
3 (3.8)
|
0 (0.0)
|
0.57
|
Symptoms
|
|
|
|
|
Any
|
93 (83.8)
|
68 (87.2)
|
20 (74.1)
|
0.13
|
Feverb
|
54 (48.6)
|
45 (57.7)
|
7 (25.9)
|
0.004
|
Chillsb
|
37 (33.3)
|
31 (39.7)
|
5 (18.5)
|
0.045
|
Cough
|
69 (62.2)
|
51 (65.4)
|
14 (51.9)
|
0.21
|
Dyspnea
|
45 (40.5)
|
37 (47.4)
|
7 (25.9)
|
0.051
|
Sore throatb
|
37 (33.3)
|
21 (26.9)
|
14 (51.9)
|
0.018
|
Headache
|
36 (32.4)
|
25 (32.1)
|
8 (29.6)
|
0.81
|
Myalgia
|
47 (42.3)
|
35 (44.9)
|
10 (37.0)
|
0.48
|
Abdominal pain
|
18 (16.2)
|
13 (16.7)
|
3 (11.1)
|
0.76
|
Nausea and vomiting
|
23 (20.7)
|
18 (23.1)
|
3 (11.1)
|
0.18
|
Diarrhea
|
35 (31.5)
|
26 (33.3)
|
6 (22.2)
|
0.28
|
Loss of smell or taste
|
39 (35.1)
|
28 (35.9)
|
6 (22.2)
|
0.19
|
Treatment
|
|
|
|
|
Oxygen support
|
15 (13.5)
|
14 (17.9)
|
1 (3.7)
|
0.11
|
Experimental SARS-CoV-2 directed therapy
|
18 (16.2)
|
17 (21.8)
|
1 (3.7)
|
0.037
|
a 6 out of 111 patients examined had intermediate serology
b Independent correlates as revealed by multivariate analysis
Abbreviations: SARS-CoV-2, severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2.
The most common presenting symptoms noted in the entire cohort were cough (62.2%), fever (48.6%) and dyspnea (40.5%) (Table 1). IgG-positive patients had significantly higher rates (compared to IgG negative patients) of fever (57.7% vs. 25.9%, p<0.0001), chills (39.7% vs. 18.5%, p=0.04) and dyspnea (47.4% vs. 25.9%, p=0.047) at presentation. Fourteen of the 15 patients who required oxygen support were positive for SARS-CoV-2 IgG, although the difference between the IgG-positive and IgG negative patients did not reach statistical significance (17.9% vs. 3.7%, p=0.11). A significantly higher proportion of IgG positive patients had received SARS-CoV-2 experimental therapies (i.e., hydroxychloroquine, azithromycin, lopinavir/ritonavir) compared to IgG negative patients (21.8% vs 3.7%, p=0.029).
Nasopharyngeal viral RNA was still detected in 23.8% of the patients at the time of serum sampling. While the detection rate of viral RNA appeared to be somewhat lower among IgG-positive patients (20.5%) compared with IgG negative patients (33.3%), this difference did not reach statistical significance (p=0.18).
Comparing additional laboratory parameters, we found that median ferritin levels were higher in the IgG positive group (129.2 vs. 78.9 mg/dL, p=0.039), whereas white blood cell and platelet counts, and CRP levels did not differ between the two groups.
A multivariate analysis identified the presence of fever (OR 5.13; 95% CI 1.53 – 17.45; p=0.008), chills (OR 6.82; 95% CI 1.60 – 29.08; p=0.009), and the time-from-diagnosis (OR 1.18; 95% CI 1.06 – 1.32; p=0.004) as independent predictors of the presence of SARS-CoV-2 IgG within the first month from diagnosis.
Semi-quantitative analysis of IgG levels
A wide (> 1 log) IgG level range was identified in IgG positive patients. Dividing the IgG positive patients into subgroups with high- and low-antibody levels (with a cutoff set at a ratio of 5.0; see Patients and Methods), we found that patients with high IgG levels were significantly older [51.0± 13.6 vs. 37.4 ±18.7 years, p<0.001]. Notably, both ferritin and CRP levels were higher in the high-IgG group with the latter showing a statistically significant difference (median ferritin levels 165.1 vs. 98.1 mg/dL, p=0.14; median CRP levels 0.36 vs. 0.07 mg/dL, p=0.001). There were no significant differences between the two subgroups with regard to the time post diagnosis, demographic and clinical parameters, and the presence of viral RNA in concurrent nasopharyngeal swab samples.