2.1 Overview of leprosy cases over time
A total of 3698 leprosy patients were registered in Chongqing from 1949 to 2018. As seen in Fig. 1(1), the incidence of leprosy in the whole city increased rapidly from a low level and then decreased to a stable low level. The incidence of leprosy increased rapidly from 0.006/105 people in 1949 to a peak of 0.848/105 people in 1960. The incidence of leprosy fluctuated within the range of 0.085/105 and 0.848/105 people from 1959 to 2002 and the decreased to 0.048/105 people in 2003. After that, the incidence of leprosy remained below 0.100/105 people. According to the above, the onset of leprosy was divided into three periods. After analyzing the change in the morbidity rate and the EAPC, it was calculated that the EAPC in incidence from 1949 to 1958 was 12.460% (P = 0.238); the change in morbidity in that period was not significant. From 1959 to 2002, the EAPC in the incidence was − 4.281% (P = 0.000), that is, the incidence rate decreased at a rate of 4.281% per year during that period. From 2003 to 2018, the incidence rate remained at a low level, at less than 0.100/105.
By the end of 2018, the city reported 98 leprosy patients. As shown in Fig. 1(2), the number of cases rose rapidly in 1959 and peaked at 1021 in 1977, with a prevalence of 3.938/105 people. By 2003, the number of cases had dropped to 169, with a prevalence of 0.540/105 people. Since then, the prevalence rate has remained below 0.600/105 people, achieving the WHO standard for the elimination of leprosy (a prevalence rate below 1/105). Moreover, the mortality rate of leprosy remained below 0.100 per 100,000 people, and the change trend was consistent with the incidence rate.
2.2 Regional Prevalence
A heat map was constructed according to the cumulative incidence of leprosy in each region from 1949 to 2018. As shown in Fig. 2, the Hechuan district had the most cases (351), followed by Fengjie County (304). According to the regional distribution, leprosy cases were more densely distributed in the northern and eastern areas than in the southern and western areas of the city. The incidence rate increased with distance from the main urban area.
2.3 Population Prevalence
2.3.1 Sex distribution
By the end of 2018, there were 2930 cases reported in males and 768 cases reported in females. The sex ratio was 3.814 to 1. As shown in Fig. 1(3), the annual incidence rate in males was significantly higher than that in females (P = 0.000). There were 73 male and 25 female leprosy patients in the whole city. The annual prevalence was significantly higher in males than in females (P = 0.000). The mortality rate in both male and female patients with leprosy remained low, and the mortality rate in male patients was significantly higher than that in female patients. The variation trends of the three rates were consistent with that of the total population rate.
2.3.2 Age Distribution
According to the existing literature, demographic data regarding the age distribution were available from only 1982 onwards. Leprosy affects residents of all ages. Among the 3698 patients, 117 children aged 1–14 years accounted for 3.164%, with an average annual incidence of 0.082/105 people. There was a total of 3445 patients who were 15–64 years old, accounting for 93.158% of the total sample, and the average annual incidence was 0.904/105 people. Among the elderly population aged 65 years and older, 136 cases occurred, accounting for 3.678%, and the average annual incidence was 0.240/105 people. Clearly, leprosy mainly occurred in people aged 15–65 years, and the average annual incidence was significantly higher in this age group than the other two age groups, as shown in Fig. 1(4).
2.4 Diagnosis, Treatment And Disease Course Of Leprosy
2.4.1 Diagnosis
The median time between the onset and diagnosis of leprosy in the whole city was 3.576(1.435, 7.621) years. A total of 1158 cases were diagnosed within 2 years, with an early detection rate of 31.314%. A total of 1170 cases were diagnosed within 2 ~ 5 years, with a detection rate of 31.639%. A total of 1370 cases were diagnosed within 5 years, with a detection rate of 37.047%. The distribution of leprosy patients with different diagnosis delay times was significantly different in different years (χ2 = 133.852, P = 0.000). As shown in Table 1, the proportion of patients diagnosed within 2 years of onset fluctuated greatly in the first 10 years but increased starting in 1964. The proportion of patients with a delayed diagnosis of 5 years or more reached a maximum of 42.395% in 1979 to 1983, followed by a downward trend.
From 1949 to 2018, a total of 1709 leprosy patients were registered as without disability at the time of diagnosis, with a disability-free rate of 50.413%. There were 598 patients with grade 1 disability, and the rate of grade 1 disability was 17.640%. There were 1083 patients with grade 2 disability, and the rate was 31.947%. The distribution of leprosy patients with different degrees of disability was significantly different in different years (χ2 = 71.885, P = 0.000);310 patients with an unknown degree of disability were not included in the analysis. The chi-square trend test for pairwise comparison showed that compared with the prevalence of grade 1 disability, the prevalence of grade 2 disability showed a significant downward trend over time (χ2 = 9.562, P = 0.002). Correlation analysis showed that disability grade was closely related to the delay in diagnosis of leprosy (r = 0.275, P = 0.000).
Table 1
Delayed diagnosis and abnormal disability in leprosy patients in the whole city from 1949 to 2018
Year
|
Onset - Diagnosis time (T)
|
|
Disability
|
T < 2 (year)
|
2 ≦ T < 5 (year)
|
T ≦ 5 (year)
|
|
No disability
|
Grade 1 disability
|
Grade 2 disability
|
1949~
|
17 (89.474%)
|
1 (5.263%)
|
1 (5.263%)
|
|
7 (58.333%)
|
1 (8.333%)
|
4 (33.333%)
|
1954~
|
20 (55.556%)
|
8 (22.222%)
|
8 (22.222%)
|
|
9 (31.034%)
|
7 (24.138%)
|
13 (44.828%)
|
1959~
|
194 (38.569%)
|
159 (31.610%)
|
150 (29.821%)
|
|
242 (58.173%)
|
41 (9.856%)
|
133 (31.971%)
|
1964~
|
128 (24.758%)
|
170 (32.882%)
|
219 (42.360%)
|
|
241 (51.386%)
|
84 (17.91%)
|
144 (30.704%)
|
1969~
|
150 (30.060%)
|
148 (29.659%)
|
201 (40.281%)
|
|
202 (45.291%)
|
97 (21.749%)
|
147 (32.960%)
|
1974~
|
132 (29.011%)
|
133 (29.231%)
|
190 (41.758%)
|
|
200 (47.281%)
|
69 (16.312%)
|
154 (36.407%)
|
1979~
|
81 (26.214%)
|
97 (31.392%)
|
131 (42.395%)
|
|
141 (49.301%)
|
50 (17.483%)
|
95 (33.217%)
|
1984~
|
121 (24.200%)
|
168 (33.600%)
|
211 (42.200%)
|
|
239 (50.743%)
|
71 (15.074%)
|
161 (34.183%)
|
1989~
|
74 (32.456%)
|
84 (36.842%)
|
70 (30.702%)
|
|
114 (50.220%)
|
51 (22.467%)
|
62 (27.313%)
|
1994~
|
56 (35.669%)
|
60 (38.217%)
|
41 (26.115%)
|
|
60 (39.735%)
|
45 (29.801%)
|
46 (30.464%)
|
1999~
|
55 (33.951%)
|
43 (26.543%)
|
64 (39.506%)
|
|
76 (49.351%)
|
25 (16.234%)
|
53 (34.416%)
|
2004~
|
44 (33.333%)
|
43 (32.576%)
|
45 (34.091%)
|
|
75 (58.140%)
|
23 (17.829%)
|
31 (24.031%)
|
2009~
|
48 (45.714%)
|
36 (34.286%)
|
21 (20.000%)
|
|
62 (59.615%)
|
20 (19.231%)
|
22 (21.154%)
|
2014~
|
38 (50.000%)
|
20 (26.316%)
|
18 (23.684%)
|
|
41 (56.164%)
|
14 (19.178%)
|
18 (24.658%)
|
2.4.2 Treatment
Before 1982, the treatment of leprosy mainly consisted of dapsone(DDS). In 1982, the WHO issued a standard regimen for the treatment of leprosy: multidrug therapy (MDT) [11]. Therefore, considering 1982 as the boundary, the data were analysed by classification and treatment plan in each period. Among the 3702 registered patients, 3274 patients had multibacillary (MB)-type leprosy (88.486%), and 426 patients had paucibacillary (PB)-type leprosy (11.534%). During the whole period, the number of MB-type patients was much higher than that of PB-type patients, with an MB:PB patient ratio of 7.685:1. As shown in Table 2, before 1982, the two leprosy treatment regimens were dominated by DDS therapy, accounting for 91.815% of the total therapeutic regimens, which was consistent with the situation during that period. After 1982, MDT-MB was the main treatment regimen for MDT-MB patients, and MDT-PB was the main treatment regimen for MDT-PB patients.
Table 2
Treatment types in and treatment plans for leprosy patients in different periods in Chongqing
Treatment
|
1949 ~ 1981
|
|
1982 ~ 2018
|
MB
|
PB
|
|
MB
|
PB
|
Untreated
|
20(1.033%)
|
3(1.200%)
|
|
16(1.197%)
|
4(2.273%)
|
DDS
|
1794(92.617%)
|
214(85.600%)
|
|
306(22.887%)
|
50(28.409%)
|
MDT-MB
|
61(3.149%)
|
1(0.400%)
|
|
965(72.177%)
|
40(22.727%)
|
MDT-PB
|
3(0.155%)
|
17(6.800%)
|
|
24(1.795%)
|
68(38.636%)
|
Other
|
59(3.046%)
|
15(6.000%)
|
|
26(1.945%)
|
14(7.955%)
|
The cure rate is shown in Fig. 1(5). From 1949 to 1981, the overall 5-year cure rates in leprosy patients in the city were lower than 30%, though they began to increase rapidly after the WHO announced the MDT treatment plan in 1982. The cure rate reached its maximum value of 41.18% in 1998 and fluctuated by approximately 20% thereafter. In terms of sex, the cumulative cure rate in males was 81.809%, and that in females was 84.245%, which was slightly higher than that in males (t =-0.616, P = 0.539). In terms of age, the cumulative cure rate was 87.179% in children aged 0–14 years old, 82.714% in patients aged 15–64 years old, and 67.647% in elderly patients aged 65 years and older. The cumulative cure rate decreased significantly with increasing age (χ2 = 17.836, P = 0.000).
The disease course in clinically cured patients is shown in Fig. 1(6); from 1949 to 1981, DDS therapy was mainly used for the treatment of leprosy. A total of 79.470% of the patients had a disease course, from diagnosis to cure, longer than 5 years, and 42.245% of the patients had a disease course longer than 10 years. After the introduction of MDT therapy in 1982, 94.741% of leprosy patients were cured within 10 years. Among these patients, 51.570% had a duration of disease less than 5 years, and the disease course in patients receiving MDT was significantly shorter than that of patients receiving DDS treatment (χ2 = 608.346, P = 0.000).