3.1 Formation and morphology of PFR
Radical polymerization reaction was employed as a convenient and simple synthesis method to obtain nanoparticles as shown in scheme 1. The morphology of nanoparticles PFR was obtained by FE-SEM. In Figure 1a, PFR exhibited nano agglomeration and the particle size was about 25~30 nm. The element and content were determined by element analysis (EA) and inductive coupled plasma emission spectrometer (ICP) as shown in Table 1. The chemical structures of PFR were estimated via FTIR (Fig. 1b). In the FTIR spectrum of PFR, the symmetric stretching vibration peaks of =C-H at about 3051 cm-1 and 2963 cm-1 disappeared. The symmetric stretching vibration peaks at about 1593 cm-1 and 1610 cm-1 attributed to C=C also disappeared. Besides, the stretching vibration peak of Si-C or P-C appeared at 840~670 cm-1 (Zope et al. 2017). The stretching vibration peak of Si-O appeared in the wavenumber range of 1090~920 cm-1 (Guo et al. 2020; Jian et al. 2020). The data indicated the successful synthesis of PFR.
Table 1 The element analysis of PFR
Element
|
C
|
H
|
O
|
Si
|
P
|
Content percentage (%)
|
42.32
|
8.75
|
24.56
|
7.31
|
16.15
|
3.2 Thermal stability of PFR
The thermal stability of PFR was analyzed by thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) under continuous nitrogen and air atmosphere from 30 oC to 700 oC. The results (Figure 1c and d) showed that the residue weight percent (CR) of PFR was 70.2% at 700 oC in nitrogen, while the CR was 30.1% in atmosphere environment. In air, PFR showed two-phase thermal degradation. The maximum decomposing rate (Tmax) occurred at about 480 ℃ in nitrogen and 240 oC. This might be due to the conversion was easier of phosphorus into phosphate and phosphonate compounds was easier in aerobic environment (Lazar et al. 2020). All the data certificated PFR had high thermal stability.
3.3 Morphology and structure of flame retardant modified cotton fibers
Cotton fibers as the original material of cotton fabric were modified with the PFR to reduce flammable property by dip-coating and radio frequency capacitively-coupled plasma (RF-CCP) treatment as shown in graphic abstract. Seen from the images of FE-SEM (Fig. 2), it could be observed that there were visible grooves and natural spirals on the surface of raw cotton fibers (Co), while plasma without dip-coating treated cotton fibers (pCo) presented obvious grooves and scratches compared with Co. The dip-coating and plasma induced crosslinking cotton fibers (pCo-PFR) apperanced attached particles on the surface compared with Co and pCo.
In order to further confirm the crosslinking reaction of PFR and cotton fibers, the FT-IR and XPS of Co and modified cotton fibers were tested. As shown in Fig. 3a, compared with the FT-IR spectrum of Co and pCo, the FT-IR spectrum of pCo-PFR exhibited obvious new absorption peak at about 1260 cm-1 and 799 cm-1, which mainly due to the stretching vibration peak of P=O and Si-C (Zope et al. 2017; Guo et al. 2020). There was no significant difference between the FT-IR spectrum of Co and pCo, except for the peak area of hydroxyl group was reduced in FT-IR spectrum of pCo. The above results indicated that one-step of plasma induced crosslinking had no obvious effect on the fiber structure or elements. New structure and element units appeared on the fiber surface after the process of dip-coating and plasma induced crosslinking. In addition, the XPS spectra corresponded to the conclusion of the FT-IR. In Fig. 3b, compared with XPS spectra of Co, the new binding energy was found on spectrum of pCo-PFR at 150.5 eV, 130.6 eV and 99.8 eV, which could be assigned to Si2s, P2p and Si2p, respectively (Chu et al. 2018). The C1s XPS spectra of Co and pCo-PFR were shown in Fig. 3c. The new peak appeared was distinguished as Me2CO (287.6 eV) on C1s XPS spectra of pCo-PFR, certificated the new structure was formed.
3.4 Thermal stability of nano flame retardant modified cotton fibers
The thermal stability of nanoparticles modified cotton fibers were assessed by thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) under continuous nitrogen from 30 oC to 700 oC. The heating rate was 10 oC/min. As shown in Fig. 4 and Table 2, the residue weight percent (CR) of pCo-PFR was 19.0 % at 700 oC. At the same test condition, the CR of Co and pCo were 3.0% and 3.2%, respectively. The CR of pCo-PFR was higher than the Co and pCo distinctly, and also higher than theoretical CR of pCo-PFR. The results confirmed that PFR not only made cotton fibers develop higher residual carbon, but also promoted the fibers to form carbon by themselves. Mass loss rate @ Tmax of pCo-PFR decreases from -34.6 %/oC to -28.7 %/oC, indicated that addition of PFR slowed down the degradation of cotton fibers. In terms of initial degradation temperature (T5%) and fastest degradation temperature (Tmax), pCo-PFR was more sensitive than Co. This phenomenon was explained by the decomposition of phosphorus to catalysis the formation of carbon in the fibers at lower temperature (Li et al. 2021).
Table 2. Thermogravimetric Data for the nano flame retardant modified cotton fibers
sample
|
T5% (oC)
|
TMax (oC)
|
Mass Loss rate @ Tmax (%/oC)
|
CR at 700 oC (%)
|
Theoretical CR (%)
|
Co
|
230.4
|
376.2
|
-34.9
|
3.0
|
3.0
|
pCo
|
135.2
|
394.5
|
-34.6
|
3.2
|
3.2
|
pCo-PFR
|
213.3
|
360.6
|
-28.7
|
19.0
|
17.8
|
3.5 Evaluation durable flame retardancy of nanoparticles modified cotton fibers
Micro calorimeter test has been recognized as one of the most acceptable fire testing apparatus for fiber materials that provides the heat release parameters information to evaluate the fire hazard (He et al. 2018). Fig. 5a and b showed the heat release rate (HRR) curves and total heat release (THR) curves of Co, pCo and pCo-PFR. The peak of heat release rate (pHRR) and THR are significant parameters for evaluating the effectiveness of flame retardant (Wu et al. 2018). It could be observed clearly that pHRR of Co was 451 W/g and the THR was 12.1 kJ/g. Compared with Co, the pHRR and THR values of pCo-PFR were decreased by 47.3 % and 29.8 %, respectively. Compared with pCo, the pHRR and THR values of pCo-PFR were reduced by 37.4 % and 28.0 %, respectively. Furthermore, time to reach peak of heat release rate (tpHRR) is also an important parameter for fire risk assessment, and longer tpHRR means more time for escaping. The data in Table 3 showed tpHRR of Co, pCo and pCo-PFR were 35 s, 34 s and 33 s, respectively. The tpHRR of pCo-PFR was shortened slightly. In order to evaluate the flame retardancy of pCo-PFR contained ignition time (TTI), pHRR and tpHRR comprehensively, the fire performance index (FPI) and fire growth index (FGI) were introduced as following equation (Hong et al. 2013):
Generally, higher FPI value and lower FGI value present a lower fire risk (Wang et al. 2018). In Table 3, FPI of Co, pCo and pCo-PFR were 0.011, 0.015 and 0.042, respectively. FGI of Co, pCo and pCo-PFR were 12.9, 11.2 and 7.2, respectively. All above data proved pCo-PFR had better property of fire suppression and providing more time to escape from the scene of fire. The flame retardant property of pCo-PFR was attributed to the destruction of cyclic combustion through synergistic effects of PFR. In addition, the results of LOI were given in Table 3. Co and pCo were easy to ignite and LOI value were about 18%, while LOI of pCo-PFR increased to 27%. The data revealed that the ignition and combustion abilities both decreased with introduction of phosphorus and silicon contents in the cotton fibers.
Table 3. Micro Calorimeter data and limit oxygen index (LOI) of Co, pCo and pCo-PFR
Sample
|
TTI
(s)
|
pHRR
(w/g)
|
THR
(kJ/g)
|
tPHRR
(s)
|
FPI
|
FGI
|
LOI (%)
|
Co
|
5
|
451
|
12.1
|
35
|
0.011
|
12.9
|
18
|
pCo
|
6
|
380
|
11.8
|
34
|
0.015
|
11.2
|
18
|
pCo-PFR
|
10
|
238
|
8.5
|
33
|
0.042
|
7.2
|
27
|
The flame retardant durability of dip-coating and plasma induced crosslinking cotton fibers was investigated by physics washing (cycle time was set as 5, 10, 30 and 50) according to ISO 6330: 2012, MOD standard. As shown in Fig. 5c and Table 4, after 50 washing cycles, the pHRR and THR of pCo-PFR were 399 W/g and 10.3 kJ/g, still decreased by 11.6 % and 14.9 % compared with Co. The data proved dip-coating and plasma induced crosslinking brought stability and durability to flame retardant modified cotton fibers.
Table 4. Durability test of pCo-PFR about heat release rate (pHRR) and total heat release (THR)
Washing circle (times)
|
0
|
5
|
10
|
30
|
50
|
pHRR (W/g)
|
246
|
251
|
292
|
354
|
399
|
THR (kJ/g)
|
8.5
|
8.7
|
9.2
|
9.9
|
10.3
|
3.6 Mechanism analyze of flame retardant modified cotton fibers
To investigate the flame retardancy mechanism in gas phase and/or condensed phase, the microstructures of the residual char were collected after combustion test and analyzed by SEM and FT-IR as shown in Fig. 6 and 7. In Fig. 6, Co presented loose and shapeless structure after combustion, which was attributed to diffuse oxygen and flammable gas forming cyclic combustion. The residue sample of pCo showed loose and chaos state. Differenced from the Co and pCo, carbon residue of pCo-PFR appeared relatively complete and kept the spiral shape of cotton fiber.
The condensed phase products at different decomposition temperatures were analyzed by FT-IR spectroscopy as shown in Fig. 7. The temperature of 330 oC, 380 oC, 430 oC and 600 oC were important decomposition period for cotton matrix in the TGA test. There was no obvious change in chemical structure whether for Co, pCo or pCo-PFR at 330 oC. Further degradation at 380 oC, the dehydrogenation of Co, pCo and pCo-PFR occurred and produced substances of aldehydes, ketones (Pastorova et al. 1993). In the FT-IR spectrum at 430 oC, the unsaturation of molecular chain in the residue carbon increased, and the conjugation of C = C and C = O made the corresponding infrared absorption peak blue shift (Zhang et al. 2021). At 600 oC, the degradation was completed basically. The carbon residue with higher C/H ratio could be obtained by deoxidation and dehydrogenation. The stretching vibration peak of Si-C (799 cm-1) was prominent in FT-IR spectrum of pCo-PFR (Li et al. 2019). The results showed that the structure of Si-C migrated to the surface of matrix and carried out condensed phase flame retardant to cut off the heat and oxygen necessary for circulating combustion with the increase of temperature (Nechyporchuk et al. 2017).
Besides, the gas phase pyrolysis of Co and pCo-PFR at 380 oC were monitored by pyrolysis gas chromatography mass spectrometry (Py-GC/MS) as shown in Fig. 8a. It was reported that decomposition of activated cotton materials was mainly through two competitive pathways (Cai et al. 2018; Qu et al. 2011). Dehydrating and charring produced a coke and a small molecule gas, meanwhile depolymerizing formed non-volatile L-glucose liquid, which was a crucial middle product of cotton during the pyrolysis process. L-glucose continuous decomposition tended to form small molecule gases and secondary coke, glycolaldehyde, tar, etc. (Zhu et al. 2016). Thus, reducing production of L-glucose meant a decrease in combustible substances. During decomposition of Co, the peak of L-glucose appeared at about 15 min. In contrast, the relative peak area of L-glucose in pCo-PFR’s Py-GC/MS spectra reduced by 29.4%. In addition, the peak area percentage of flammable gases produced also decreased by pCo-PFR as shown in Fig. 8, such as furans ((1) and (2)), alcohols ((2) and (3)), ketones (4) and aldehydes (5). The nonflammable small molecules contained phosphorus and silicon elements (6) were produced from the cracking process of pCo-PFR.
So, P and Si elements endowed nanoparticles flame-retardant function through two aspects. In condensed phase, the PFR mediated the formation of char by inducing cyclization, crosslinking, and aromatization/graphitization by dehydration of the polymeric structure. The formation of carbonaceous char reduces the release of volatiles (Camino et al. 2001; Schartel et al. 2016;). In the gas phase, the PFR slow down heat transfer via radical generators and non-flammable gases (Bourbigot et al. 2004; Lazar et al. 2020).
3.7 Mechanical properties
The Mechanical properties of Co, pCo and pCo-PFR were shown in Fig. 9a, b and Table 5. It was found that the breaking strength of Co, pCo and pCo-PFR were 4.22 cN, 3.93 cN and 3.79 cN, respectively. The breaking strength of pCo-PFR was decreased by 10.2 % than that of Co. Linear density of pCo-PFR was slightly higher than that of Co. Considering the fiber fineness, the fracture strength of single fiber of Co, pCo and pCo-PFR were 2.78, 2.49 and 2.26 cN/dtex. Besides, elongation at break of pCo-PFR reduced 8.4 % compared with Co. The mechanical property test showed that the dip-coating and plasma induce crosslinking modification had limited damage of mechanical property to cotton fibers.
Table 5. Mechanical properties of Co, pCo and pCo-PFR
Sample
|
Breaking strength (cN/dtex)
|
Elongation at break (%)
|
Linear density (dtex)
|
Co
|
2.77
|
7.25
|
1.52
|
pCo
|
2.49
|
6.51
|
1.58
|
pCo-PFR
|
2.26
|
6.64
|
1.68
|