Geminiviruses inflict huge crop losses and pose a great threat to food security [17]. Different strategies, like protein mediated resistance, RNA mediated resistance, host derived resistance etc, have been developed to tackle this pathogen but these strategies failed due to the high rate of evolution and recombination of a virus [1]. The virus is able to modify its genome quickly and counter these strategies [4]. In past, different approaches have been followed to create resistance against plant DNA viruses. For example, Pathogen derived resistance (PDR) against Tomato yellow leaf curl Sardinia virus (TYLCSV) by targeting the Rep protein has been developed. This resistance was challenged, and the transgene was silenced by virus exploiting its own defense mechanism known as virus induced gene silencing (VIGS; [16]). Similar results were observed for Bean golden mosaic virus (BGMV) where resistance against the virus was created by targeting the coat protein. Moreover, mutating a Rep gene was used to confer resistance against BGMV but it was again dependent on the viral titer i.e. when the viral titer was higher the resistance mechanism failed to develop [8]. Additionally, Artificial Zinc finger Protein (AZP) was used to target IR of Beet severe curly top virus (BSCTV; [24]). Furthermore, it was observed that zinc finger nucleases (ZFN) performed better than AZP as they not only block a virus binding site but also cleave the viral genome. Transcription activator like effectors (TALEs) have been reported to provide resistance against Tomato yellow leaf curl China virus (TYLCCNV), Tobacco curly shoot virus (TbCSV) and Tomato leaf curl Yunnan virus [5], but these TALE nucleases were not yet known for developing resistance against DNA viruses due to cost and difficulty [28].
The CRISPR-Cas9 system identified in bacteria and archaea provided molecular immunity to fend off the invading phages. This system provides an opportunity for bioengineers to manipulate this system which could then be used to edit or modify genomes, and regulate gene expression and epigenome manipulation. Therefore, this system can be harnessed for genome engineering and to create molecular resistance against DNA viruses by targeting highly conserved regions of the virus or targeting host genes that interact with virus particles. In this study, we have employed CRISPR-Cas9 to selectively target the highly conserved IR region of CLCuKoV-Bur. Our data showed that CRISPR-Cas9 system can initiate molecular interference against plant DNA viruses.
In this study, we observed the most efficient virus interference by targeting IR region of CLCuKoV-Bur simultaneously at two (gRNA1 and gRNA2) points. Our results are consistent and in agreement with other studies. For example, Ali et al. [2] have demonstrated viral interference against CLCuKoV by targeting coding (coat protein and RCRII domain of replication associated protein) and non-coding (IR) regions. Their finding suggests that targeting IR regions would provide better interference as compared to coding regions. However, all the results were obtained in transient assay. Here we have developed transgenic lines and challenged them with CLCuKoV-Bur/CLCuMB. Similar conclusions were drawn when CRISPR-Cas9 was used against Cotton Leaf curl Multan virus [28].
Our research study provides insight into the exploitation of the CRISPR-Cas9 system as a successful tool for DNA virus interference. It has been shown that targeting highly conserved IR at multiple sites following a multiplex approach can provide almost complete resistance against CLCuKoV-Bur strain. Since, we were unable to detect any intact virus using gene specific and virus specific primers; or by Southern hybridization. There are multiple possibilities for not detecting intact virus particles; the repair process might result in variants incapable of replication, or more likely, amplicons with long deletions would also be incapable of replication. The latter explanation seems to be most relevant because this IR region also contains a bidirectional promoter region. By disrupting this region there is a high possibility to restrain virus replication. Our findings are in agreement with other studies [2] in which they have shown that virus variants having modifications in IR were unable to replicate.
It is worth noting that different approaches; targeting coat protein, Replication associated protein and IR at the same time using a multiplex approach, as well as different gRNAs and delivery systems can be used to improve virus interference. Further studies are needed to reveal the molecular underpinnings involved in virus-host interaction so more targets can be chosen and susceptible genes can be targeted that will result in enhanced immunity against these viruses.