This section presents the results obtained to produce the biocatalyst, the effect of the substrate concentration on the hydrolysis of sucrose in batch reactors and the effect of different factors on the hydrolysis of sucrose in packed-bed reactors under continuous operation.
3.1 Invertase production by SSF
Invertase production was performed by SSF in tubular bioreactors. To determine the incubation time for the maximum invertase production, samples were taken at 40, 45 and 60 h of culture. Maximum invertase activity (82.2 U/g db) was reached at 45 h. Invertase can be produced by various organisms, including some animals, plants, bacteria, yeasts and fungi [19]. Due to the importance and widespread application of invertase in various industries, its isolation from natural sources is not affordable. Instead, it is recommended to use yeasts, fungi or bacteria to produce invertase [19].
Table 1 shows some sources of invertase, the enzyme activity and the culture time to reach the maximum enzyme activity. Different studies of invertase production with yeast have shown a range of enzymatic activity of 38–118 U/mL and a culture time of 30–48 h. The results obtained in this work are within this range (82.2 U/g db in 45 h). The enzymatic activity is similar to that reported for A. niger ATCC 20611 (100.6 U/mL) cultured in submerged fermentation with sucrose as carbon source [25]; however, this activity was attained within 96 h. We selected 45 h as the culture time to produce the biocatalyst, since at 40 and 60 h, the invertase activity is lower, with 53.7 and 69.3 U/g db, respectively.
3.2 Biocatalyst production
In this work, A. niger biocatalyst production was performed in 10 tubular bioreactors incubated for 45 h, as indicated in Section 3.1. At the end of the culture, the fermented solids were air-dried to obtain the biocatalyst with a moisture content lower than 1.7%. After analysis of the extracellular and the total enzymatic activity in the biocatalysts, 50% of the activity was found extracellular. This extracellular fraction was washed during the successive batch and the continuous processes. This extra/intracellular activity was similar to that reported by Vargas et al. [9]. The auto-immobilised (total) invertase activity (40.6 U/g db) was lower than that reported by Prodanovic et al. [28] (5,500 U/g), Mansfeld et al. [1] (1,000 U/g) Szymanskaet et al. [29] (600 U/g) and Cabrera et al. [2] (179 U/g). However, all these values correspond to the enzymatic activity obtained after downstream steps and enzyme immobilisation.
3.3 Batch hydrolysis
Batch studies were performed to determine the effect of temperature (from 20 to 80ºC) on the sucrose hydrolysis rate. Experiments were conducted in test tubes containing 50 mg of biocatalyst and 1 mL of substrate (0.1 M sucrose in 0.1 M acetate buffer at pH 5). After 60 min of the enzymatic reaction, we added 9 mL of 0.04 N H2SO4 to stop the reaction. The reducing sugars release increased with temperature, with a maximum value at 70ºC and a strong reduction at 80ºC (Fig. 1). The reducing sugar release rate increased 3.3 times from 20 to 70ºC (Table 2). Based on the velocity data from 20 to 50°C, the activation energy (Ea) was calculated. The Q10 coefficient was calculated from 20 to 30°C, and the obtained value (1.49) indicates that the reaction rate increases by 49% when the temperature is changed from 20 to 30°C. The Ea value (29.7 kJ/mol) corresponds to the typical values of activation energy for diffusive processes (25.1–30.1 kJ/mol) in which mass transfer limitations are suspected. This profile was similar to that obtained with the invertase from C. utilis [30]. In our study, invertase showed activity in the interval of 30–90°C and reached its maximum activity at 70°C. The invertase produced by Saccharomyces cerevisiae SAA-612 was stable between 30 and 60°C, with a half-life between 65 h and 30 min [20]. The invertase produced by Azotobacter chroococcum had an optimal sucrose hydrolysis temperature of 45°C; however, at 30°C the enzyme had 90% of its maximum hydrolysis rate [31].
In the case of invertase produced by Aspergillus strains, the temperature at which they present their highest activity is lower than that reported in this work; for example, the temperature for the highest invertase activity for A. terreus is 60°C [24], similar to that reported for the invertase produced by A. niger IBK1 [26]. A temperature above 60ºC is preferable for industrial invert sugar production to reduce the viscosity of the solutions and decrease the risk of contamination [5]. Based on our results, we determined the temperature range where invertase activity was observed; in addition, the naturally immobilised invertase produced by A. niger C28B25 was capable of hydrolysing sucrose solutions.
3.4 Continuous hydrolysis with different sucrose concentrations
Once the impacts of the reaction temperature on the enzyme stability and the sucrose hydrolysis rate were evaluated under batch conditions, the effect of the sucrose concentration and the feed flow rate on the hydrolysis rate and sucrose conversion efficiency were evaluated under the continuous feed of a 5-mL stainless-steel bioreactor. Sucrose (from 0.1 to 2 M) was fed at 6 mL/h for 40 h at 40ºC to reduce enzyme denaturation. The reducing sugar release increased from 0.1 to 1.8 M sucrose (Fig. 2), and the release rate increased 5.6 times from 0.1 to 2 M sucrose (Table 3). These results suggest that the hydrolytic reaction is not limited by any enzyme inhibition mechanism (Table 3). Concentrated sucrose solutions [near 2 M] are recommended for industrial purposes [28]. It has been observed that the sucrose concentration has a marked effect on free invertase; a sucrose concentration greater than 50 g/L decreases the activity of the free enzyme [32]. The biocatalyst produced by SSF could hydrolyse concentrated sucrose solutions (2 M) at 40°C; in Section 3.3, the temperature interval for the batch hydrolysis of sucrose was established. However, it is necessary to know the effect of temperature for the continuous hydrolysis of sucrose.
3.5 Continuous hydrolysis at different temperatures
To determine the effect of temperature (from 40 to 80ºC) on the enzymatic hydrolysis under a continuous operation regime, a 20-mL stainless-steel bioreactor was used. The substrate solution (2 M sucrose) was fed at a flow rate of 6 mL/h for 40 h. The release of reducing sugars increased when the temperature increased, reaching the highest production at 70°C in a bioreactor continuously for 40 h (Fig. 3). This result is important if we consider the origin of the catalyst used in this work. For example, Soares et al. (2019) [13] used a stirred tank reactor operating under batch conditions with ultrasound to hydrolyse sucrose with commercial invertase produced by Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The authors report a production similar to that found in our study (Fig. 3), albeit with a lower production temperature (55°C). Further, the period for which it remained stable was 8 times shorter than that reported in this work (40 h). In all cases, the initial hydrolysis was close to 100%. Subsequently, a decrease was observed in the conversion for all conditions studied, most likely because of the extracellular invertase present in the biocatalyst, representing nearly 50% of the total activity (see Section 3.2). These temperatures are similar to those used for the continuous hydrolysis of sucrose with yeast cells immobilised on wool, where temperatures between 40 and 70°C have been used, finding the highest conversion of sucrose at 70°C in a reactor with 1.2 cm in diameter and 220 cm in length, with a flow of 204 mL/h and a constant hydrolysis not below 50% for 60 days [5].
The invertase immobilised in polystyrene for the continuous hydrolysis of sucrose showed a range similar to that used in this work (40 to 70°C), although the reactors used with invertase immobilised in polystyrene are of greater volume (0.3 and 50 L) [1]. For the immobilised enzyme of Cladosporium cladosporioides [33], the temperature higher conversion of sucrose is similar to that reported for this work (70°C); however, the sucrose concentration and the period with stable enzyme (5% and 3 h, respectively) were lower than those found for the naturally immobilised enzyme from A. niger by SSF.
3.6 Continuous hydrolysis in a 20- and 200-mL reactor
When the residence time increases, the contact period between the enzymes and the substrates is longer, resulting in higher conversions. First, the effect of the feeding rate (1.2 and 3.6 mL/h) on continuous hydrolysis was evaluated. The 20-mL stainless-steel bioreactor with 4.48 g of dry biocatalyst was used at 60°C, with 2 M sucrose and a flow rate of 1.2 mL/h (hydraulic residence time 16.67 h). A baseline near 100% hydrolysis (Fig. 4a) was achieved. After 20 h, hydrolysis remained constant at 58.9 ± 5.2% after 140 h operation (representing more than 8 residence times). At 70 h of operation, the feed flow was increased to 3.6 mL/h (hydraulic residence time 5.56 h). A decrease in conversion was observed and recovered from 120 h of continuous operation (Fig. 4a). This behaviour is similar to that reported by Mukherjee et al. [34], namely that invertase immobilised on silica monoliths with hierarchical structure pores for hydrolysis continuous sucrose. The authors reported that when decreasing the residence time of 3.5 s to 0.4 s, conversion decreased from 88 to 44%.
In our study, hydrolysis was sensitive to small changes in the flow rate. To reduce fluctuations in flow rate, it was decided to use a larger column (200 mL) packed with 51.1 g of biocatalyst with a flow of 12 mL/h (hydraulic residence time 16.67 h). A similar behaviour was observed (Fig. 4b), with initial hydrolysis of 100% and a rapid decrease, reaching 55.4 + 4.8% of sucrose hydrolysis for a period of 75 h of continuous operation (approximately 5 residence times). By increasing the reactor volume, hydrolysis was not affected.
Cell systems with immobilised invertase to hydrolyse sucrose can provide economic advantages over systems with free enzymes, also achieving hydrolysis percentages as high as those reported for the auto-immobilised enzyme Cladosporium cladosporioides, reaching 94.2% of hydrolysis at 70°C [33], greater than that reported for the enzyme used in this study. However, the sucrose concentration used and the time that the enzyme remained stable were considerably decreased (5% sucrose and 3 h, respectively). In systems with commercial enzymes, sucrose hydrolysis was studied in continuous experiments with yeast-immobilised wool [5], achieving a hydrolysis of 2.0 M sucrose not less than 50% at 70°C, with flows of 180–240 mL/min and a retention time of approximately 9 min. These systems remained stable for a period of 30 days, after which this percentage decreased. With immobilised invertase in polystyrene [1], hydrolysing sucrose solutions up to 2.5 M, 80% hydrolysis and a stability period of 360 days could be achieved. Recently, Szymanska et al. [29] immobilised invertase in silica monoliths with hierarchical structure pores and an activity of 600 U/mL for continuous hydrolysis of sucrose; the system remained stable for 2 weeks.
When directly applying enzymes produced by SSF naturally immobilised, the results were superior to those reported by Buenrostro-Figueroa et al. [35], who found the greatest conversion (32%) early in the process, with a decrease to 19% for 4 h of continuous operation at a concentration of 0.1% substrate w/v. In our case, the initial conversion was greater than 90% in most cases, and more than 50% retained activity for 70 h continuous operation with a substrate concentration of 68% w/v. Both studies were conducted in a packed-bed reactor. It should be mentioned that although the method of producing the enzymes was similar, the produced enzymes and substrates used were not the same, which might explain the large differences between the two studies.