3.1. Ascorbate concentrations in blood after continuous infusions.
During the continuous infusion clinical trial, the levels of ascorbate were measured before intervention, every day for the first four days and then at the end of each week. Pre-treatment measurements demonstrated that patients had hypovitaminosis C, with two thirds of the subjects having levels below the normal range (0.6mg/dL-2mg/dL) [12, 13]. During IVC treatment, ascorbate levels increased, and reached a plateau, but average maximum values did not differ significantly between different doses and were in the range of 1.2 mM -1.5 mM. The ascorbate concentrations in blood for low (150 mg/kg/day) and high (710 mg/kg/day) dosages, averaged for all patients in these dosage groups, are presented in Figure 1.
Figure 1. Time course of the average ascorbate concentrations in blood for continuous infusions with dosages 150 mg/kg/day (black circles) and 710 mg/kg/day (black squares). Data were extrapolated by Michaelis-Menten equation.
3.2. Effect of continuous infusion on ALC
The effect of continuous infusions on the absolute lymphocyte count (ALC) was analyzed for 22 patients from 24 terminally ill cancer patients. More than half of the patients enrolled in the study had lymphopenia or absolute lymphocyte counts less than 1300 cells/µl (normal range 1300-4000 cells/µl). The data of the patients’ diagnosis, lymphocyte and neutrophil counts one week before treatments, at the beginning and end of the treatment, and the duration and the dosages of the treatments are shown in Table 1.
Table 1. Characteristics of twenty-four cancer patients (diagnosis, duration/dosages of treatment, and pretreatment, initial and final lymphocyte and neutrophil counts) who participated in a phase I clinical trial of continuous IVC infusions.
Dosage (mg/kg/d)
|
Diagnosis
|
Time
(weeks)
|
ALC
pre
|
ALC initial
|
ALC post
|
ANC initial
|
ANC post
|
150
|
Colon Cancer/ Liver Mets
|
3
|
1230
|
980
|
1056
|
5180
|
7392
|
150
|
Colon Cancer/ Liver Mets
|
8
|
|
944
|
1751
|
9417
|
8443
|
150
|
Colon Cancer/ Wall Mets
|
7
|
2162
|
1168
|
1584
|
5480
|
5565
|
290
|
Colon Cancer/ Liver Mets
|
8
|
|
1261
|
755
|
7178
|
9887
|
290
|
Colon Cancer/Liver Mets
|
2
|
420
|
518
|
897
|
6052
|
5589
|
290
|
Appendix/ Carcinomatosis
|
7
|
1850
|
1494
|
3843
|
5199
|
7002
|
290
|
Liver Cancer
|
8
|
|
552
|
1035
|
5727
|
4913
|
290
|
Colon Cancer/Liver Mets
|
6
|
1045
|
1188
|
573
|
3896
|
4341
|
290
|
Colon Cancer/ Omentum
|
8
|
1170
|
902
|
2058
|
5924
|
6302
|
430
|
Colon Cancer/Lung Mets
|
7
|
2232
|
1971
|
1795
|
3988
|
5341
|
430
|
Colon Cancer/Lung Mets
|
3
|
1296
|
1560
|
1044
|
8748
|
9512
|
430
|
Colon Cancer/Liver Mets
|
8
|
1392
|
1170
|
1365
|
6218
|
7146
|
430
|
Colon Cancer/Liver Mets
|
8
|
4712
|
4712
|
7752
|
4826
|
5515
|
430
|
Colon Cancer
|
6
|
2048
|
2205
|
1610
|
3151
|
3165
|
430
|
Pancreas Cancer
|
8
|
266
|
245
|
299
|
2576
|
3767
|
430
|
Rectal Cancer/ Liver, Lung Mets
|
3
|
1178
|
1311
|
1605
|
4906
|
4051
|
570
|
Colon Cancer/ Liver Mets
|
8
|
1400
|
1590
|
1270
|
2934
|
3124
|
570
|
Pancreas Cancer/ Liver Mets
|
7
|
777
|
663
|
999
|
2969
|
5781
|
570
|
Colon Cancer/Lung Mets
|
8
|
1260
|
355
|
836
|
6048
|
5499
|
710
|
Colon Cancer/Liver, Lung Mets
|
8
|
1512
|
972
|
1055
|
5571
|
6100
|
710
|
Colon Cancer/Liver, Lung Mets
|
8
|
|
936
|
915
|
3432
|
4062
|
710
|
Cholangiocarcinoma/Liver Mets
|
0.3
|
|
2496*
|
|
15600
|
9271
|
710
|
Esophagus Cancer/Liver Mets
|
1.5
|
|
663*
|
|
3723
|
6424
|
710
|
Colon Cancer/Liver Mets
|
8
|
496
|
624
|
1075
|
8249
|
5470
|
*Excluded from the data analysis due to lack of post treatment data.
The percentage of change in ALC was calculated based on the pre-treatment ALC (6-12 days before intervention), initial ALC values and the ALC at the end of the treatment. According to our data, the tendency of ALC was to decrease in 56% of patients before treatment. For patients with lymphopenia (15 subjects) the improvement or stabilization of the count was seen in all patients except for one subject. For this group of patients the median values of ALC was 940 cells/µl (IQR 588-1168 cells/µl) at the beginning of treatment and 1045 (IQR 866-1420 cells/µl) at the end of the treatment (p-value = 0.03). On average, there was a 22% of improvement in lymphocyte counts for all patients who completed 6-8 weeks of treatment and had ALC <1300 /µl (IQR: 89%, -24%). For five patients, the ALC values returned to the normal level (ALC>1300 cells/µl) and for five patients the values reached the level of 1000 cells/µl. Distribution of the ALC before and after treatment and percentage of ALC improvement for patients with initial ALC less than normal range and in normal range are shown in Figure 2.
Figure 2. Distributions of the percentage of change in absolute lymphocyte counts before and after treatment (A); Percentage of improvement of ALC for patients with initial lymphocyte counts lower than normal range (ALC<1300/µl) and in normal range (B).
Severe lymphopenia (ALC<1000 cells/µl) was measured in 10 patients. Only six patients with severe lymphopenia completed 6-8 weeks of treatment. On average, for the six patients with the ALC <1000 cells/µl, there was a 69% improvement in the lymphocyte count at the end of the treatment (IQR: 129%, -6%).
For all patients who completed 6-8 weeks of treatment (18 subjects), we analyzed the dosage effect of vitamin C on the improvement in lymphocyte counts. At the low doses of continuous infusions (combined 150 and 300 mg/kg/day) the median increase in lymphocyte counts was 35% (IQR (-11%÷107%), for high doses (430, 570, and 710 mg/kg/day) the median change in lymphocyte counts were, respectively, 6% (IQR: -22%÷28%), 22% (IQR: 1%÷36%) and -16% (IQR: -25%÷-8%). The dependence of the percentage of ALC change on dosage of continuous infusion is shown in Figure 3. These data indicate that lower doses are more favorable for the improvement of lymphocyte count.
Figure 3. The dosage effect of vitamin C on the change in lymphocyte counts.
3.3 The effect of continuous infusion on ANC
As absolute neutrophil counts (ANC) and neutrophil-to-lymphocyte (NLR) ratios are useful prognostic factors in a variety of cancers, with higher values of NLR indicating lower survival times [14], the effect of continuous injection on these parameters was analyzed. First, we compared the initial and final values of ANC for the patients treated by continuous infusion and who completed 6-8 weeks of treatment. The normal range for ANC is 2000-7000 cell/µl. During analysis the ANC values were divided into three ranges: ANC less than the middle of the normal range (2000-4500cell/µl), higher than the middle of normal range (4500-7000cells/µl) and higher than normal range. The distributions of the changes between initial and post ANC are shown in Figure 4. The median percentage change with IQR for these three regions were 22.7% (IQR: 5%-58%), 8% (IQR:-10%-20%) and -22%, respectively.
ANC values were higher than normal range for two patients with metastatic colon cancer (8250 cells/μl and 9417cell/μl) and decreased after treatment by 10% and 37%. Two patients with pancreatic cancer with metastasis had the initial levels of ANC on the lower level of the normal range (2570 cells/μl and 2930 cells/μl), which increased by 46% and 94% at the end of the treatment. For the rest of the patients, the tendency was for normalization of the values, i.e. improvement of ANC at the low level of this parameter and decreasing for the higher values.
Figure 4. Dependence of the ANC change on the initial cell counts for continuous treatment. The levels of ANC were divided to three regions: less than the middle of the normal range (2000-4500cell/µl, n=6), higher than the middle of normal range (4500-7000cells/µl, n=10) and higher than normal range (ANC>7000 cells/µl, n=2). The normal range for neutrophil counts is 2000-7000 cells/µl.
3.4 The effect of continuous infusions on NLR
At the beginning of IVC therapy, 75 % of subjects had NLR levels higher than normal range (0.78 - 3.53). An improvement in the NLR was seen in 36% of the patients. However, for continuous infusions we were able to calculate the tendency in the change of NLR before and during treatment, as the values for ALC and ANC were measured a week before treatment, at the beginning, and each week during treatment. To calculate the initial ΔNLR (prior to therapy), NLR on day zero was subtracted from NLR measured one week prior to therapy, and this difference was divided by the number of days between the two measurements. The rate of change in this ratio (ΔNLR) for each patient before and after therapy was described in our previous article [13]. The comparison of the trend in the change of NLR measured for periods one week before treatment and during treatment demonstrated that the rate of change was decreased. The average ΔNLR values for the patients who completed 6-8 weeks of treatment were 4.2%/day pre-therapy and 1.0 %/ day post-therapy (Figure 5).
Figure 5. The rate of NLR changes (percentage per day) before and after treatment for patients who completed 6-8 weeks of treatment.
According to our data, the treatment resulted in the suppression or prevention of the progression of the rate of growth of NLR. This improvement of the rate of change of NLR was found for 54% of the patients. For patients with initial NLR higher than the upper level of the normal range of 3.5, improvement was seen in 64% of patients who completed 6-8 weeks of treatment.