The factors affecting squatting ability after TKA had not been reported in the literature. The main finding of this study was that joint line was the only significant factor that affecting squatting ability in patients after TKA.
Majority of literatures had reported the factors affecting range of motion after TKA. However, no previous studies had reported the factors affected the patient's squatting ability after TKA. In Asian populations, activities such as cross-legged sitting, kneeling, and squatting are an important part of daily activities(4). Therefore, it’s necessary and important to clarify the influencing factors of squatting.
Some literatures reported that sex had no correlation in affecting the knee ROM postoperatively after total knee arthroplasty(13–15). Bellemans J et al(16).found the use of standard implants could lead to mediolateral overhang in women, causing irritation and pain of the soft tissue capsular envelope of the knee because of female knees were narrower than male knees. However, the results of this study show that the relationship between gender and clinical outcomes remains uncertain. In our study, gender was not a factor that influenced patients' squats. But the women in our study were the majority, which may have influenced our final results.
Sancheti KH et al(17). found that age and patella replacement didn’t affect the postoperative joint ROM, whereas BMI had a negative influence on postoperative joint. In our study, age was related to postoperative squatting in univariate analysis, but after multivariate analysis, age, BMI and patella replacement proved not to be the influencing factors of postoperative squatting. The study of Razzaki T et al(18). was specifically about the relationship between BMI and clinical outcome in patients following TKA. In this study, Razzaki T et found the mean 2-year Knee Society Knee Score was significantly higher in the patients who gained weight while the patients who lost weight had the highest mean 2-year Oxford Knee Score and the lowest mean 2-year Knee Society Function Score, and weight change following TKA does not affect clinical outcomes, which remain good across all BMI groups.
Physiological patellofemoral joint motion was important for knee flexion function. ISR < 0.8 was defined as patella baja (PB). PB was known to affect patellofemoral joint motion; a shortening of more than 10% of the tendon has been hypothesized to significantly reduce knee flexion due to shortening of the extensor mechanism length(9, 19, 20). There were also many reports in the literature that patella baja can restrict the ROM of the knee(21–23). However, recent studies had shown that patella baja doesn’t affect the patient's postoperative range of motion(24, 25). In our study, patella baja(P༞0.1) was also not the influencing factors of whether squatting. Bellemans et al.(26) defined a parameter termed “posterior condylar offset(PCO amount of posterior projection of the femoral implant to the tangent of the posterior femoral cortex).” Bellemans et al. found PCO was associated with a postoperative change in flexion angle in CR knees, whereas this correlation was not observed in PS knees. Yang et al.(27) found PCO didn’t seem to have a significant influence on the postoperative knee flexion after PS TKA. The prostheses of the patients in our study were all PS knees, which also explained why PCO had no effect on the postoperative squatting ability in our findings.
Oversizing the implant could theoretically increase tension and capsule/ligament friction on the implant, thus affecting clinical outcomes(28). Bonnin MP et al.(28) found oversizing of the lateral side of the prosthesis was a factor that may predicted poor TKA results, and surgeons avoided selecting oversized prostheses. Therefore, we included the prosthesis size and FC/FM to determine whether these would affect the patient's squatting ability in our study. The results showed that neither the model of the prosthesis nor FC/FM can affect squatting ability after TKA. We consider that the reason for this result is that this surgeon has a superb surgical technique and can accurately select the appropriate prosthesis model for different patients, because it can be seen from our data that the FC/FM(0.88 ± 0.09vs0.87 ± 0.06) of the group I and the group II are similar, so we cannot be sure the model of the prosthesis and FC/FM didn’t affect the squatting ability.
Gatha NM et al.(29) assessed whether specific preoperative and postoperative variables were associated with postoperative ROM in 135 patients who underwent TKA. Their results showed that preoperative ROM was the only significant predictor of postoperative ROM. Ritter et al. (30) retrospectively reviewed more than 4,700 total knee arthroplasty procedures and used regression tree analysis to describe the combination of variables affecting postoperative ROM. The primary predictor of postoperative ROM in this study was preoperative ROM. In a recent study, Konrads C et al.(31) demonstrated preoperative ROM is a good predictor of postoperative ROM after primary TKA. The results of these studies were similar to those of our study, in which preoperative ROM was also a contributing factor affecting postoperative squatting ability of patients.
Mean joint line elevation 1.1–5.6 mm after primary TKA(32). Some studies had reported a correlation between elevated joint lines and patients' postoperative range of motion(24, 33, 34), while others had found no such correlation(35). There were currently many explanations for why elevated joint lines lead to reduced range of motion after TKA. One view was that elevation of the joint line could lead to mid-flexion instability which reduced the range of motion after TKA(36).Matziolis et al.(37) also found Joint line position was associated with mid-flexion instability, which could lead to reduced range of motion after TKA. The term “mid-flexion instability” was a definition to describe instability during flexion–extension movement, which had not been proven as a unique type of instability in clinical practice(38).But another view is that joint line elevation causing patella baja can result in reduced the force of the extensor mechanism, patellar impingement on the insert caused anterior knee pain, and tightening of collateral ligaments and diminished femoral rollback resulted in limited knee motion(39). In our study, we performed univariate analysis with both patella baja and joint line elevation as influencing factors, and the results showed that patella baja was not a factor affecting ROM after TKA. Therefore, in view of our results, joint line elevation led to mid-flexion instability, which was the reason affected squatting ability of patients after TKA.
There were also limitations in this study. First, our study included limited generalizability as our cohort belongs to a single surgeon and a single institution, and women made up the majority. Second, we only preliminarily defined squatting according to the flexion angle of the knee joint in the weight-bearing position, because there is no formal definition of squatting in patients after TKA.