Lived experience of women who underwent early removal of long-acting Contraceptive Methods: A phenomenological study

doi:10.21203/rs.3.rs-86831/v1

Download PDF

Research Article

Lived experience of women who underwent early removal of long-acting Contraceptive Methods: A phenomenological study

https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-86831/v1

This work is licensed under a CC BY 4.0 License

Version 1

posted

You are reading this latest preprint version

Background: Long-acting contraceptive methods can play a pivotal role in reducing maternal mortality. In Etiopia, the total fertility rate per woman is 4.6. However, this rapid population growth is not in line with the weak economic growth of the country. Therefore, this study was performed to explore the lived experiences of women who underwent early removal of long-acting contraceptive methods in Bedesa town, Southern Ethiopia.

Methods: A phenomenological study design was employed to include a total of 10 in-depth interviews of sampled women. Participants were recruited through the criterion sampling method. Open code version 4.03 was used to code and facilitate analysis. Transcripts were read and re-read separately to identify emerging themes. A thematic analysis technique was used.

Results: This study revealed that the side effects of long-acting family planning methods were the main reason for early removal. Furthermore, heavy and irregular menses were mentioned as the most frequently occurring side effects. Delayed fertility after removal of long-acting contraceptives was one of the most frequently stated fears by clients. It was also stated that counseling provided by health professionals was not adequate.

Conclusion: The majority of study participants taught that the side effects of long-acting family planning methods outweigh the benefits. In addition, the counseling services provided by health care providers were not adequate. Therefore, proper counseling services should be given to mothers who are taking long-acting family planning methods.

Obstetrics & Gynecology

Family planning

long-acting family planning method

early removal

Bedesa

Family planning (FP) is a low-cost yet effective method of preventing maternal health problems [1, 2]. There are two types of contraceptive methods: short acting and long-acting and permanent methods. Long-acting methods can be used for both limiting and spacing childbirth, while permanent methods are used only for limiting childbirths. Short-acting methods are suitable for women who want to space childbirths [3].

Long-acting contraceptive methods can play a key role in reducing maternal mortality. It can also significantly reduce the number of unintended births[4]. Moreover, avoiding barriers to the use of contraceptives and enhancing the demand for family planning could prevent 54 million unintended pregnancies. In addition, it could prevent more than 79,000 maternal and one million infant deaths per year [5].

In Ethiopia, it is common to have a large family size with a shorter birth interval. The total fertility rate in Ethiopia is as high as 4.6 children per woman. However, this rapid population growth is not in line with the weak economic growth of the country. Such an imbalance between population size and economic growth will certainly have a negative impact on the wellbeing of the nation. Family planning is considered the key strategy used to improve the imbalance mentioned above and tackle existing problems [6].

According to the EDHS 2016 report , the discontinuation rates of Implant and IUD were 35% and 11%, respectively. Another mixed method study conducted by FMOH showed that 17% of the women removed their Implanon before the recommended removal date [7]. A similar study conducted in the Tigray region showed that the Implanon discontinuation rate in 1 year was 16% [8, 9]. The most common reasons for discontinuation are the desire to become pregnant, side effects, wanting a more effective method, infrequent sex or husband away, and inconvenience of use [10].

The Wolaita Zone is characterized by a crude population density of 385 people/square kilometer [6]. Providing the most effective contraceptive methods is a vital strategy for the improvement of balancing population growth with the economic growth of the locality. Thus, this study aimed to explore the lived experience of mothers who underwent early removal of long-acting contraceptive methods in the study area.

A phenomenological study design was used to explore the lived experience of sampled women in Bedesa town, southern Ethiopia. Women aged 15-49 years who removed long-acting therapy in the past 12 months were included. A criterion sampling approach was employed to recruit 10 participants. The interview continued until information saturation was reached. Data were collected through in-depth interviews (IDIs) using an interview guide. The interview guide consisted of basic sociodemography, desire for family size, knowledge and experiences of family planning, advantages, perceived side effects of long-acting family planning, perceptions about FP, partner involvement and peer pressure concerning the use of family planning, professional support and plans for family planning. This recruitment was facilitated through the head of the health center. Every study participant was encouraged to openly discuss their opinions. All interviews were conducted in a separate quiet room to avoid interruption from outside. Each IDI lasted for approximately 30 to 38 min. Each team checked the contents of the respective interviews. Interviews were conducted in the Amharic language. The free flow of information was encouraged through probing. To ensure the quality of the interviews, interviewers repeated the summary of interviews to study participants. The team members checked the text of each interview twice. All interviews were tape-recorded with the consent of interviewees. A unique identification number was assigned to all the recorded files. Audio data were transcribed verbatim and translated to English. The data were first saved in plain text format and imported into open code software version 4.03 to facilitate coding and categorizing. The coding process began with reading each transcript multiple times and their respective translations to ensure a degree of standardization. The coded data were compared and organized into groups. Finally, the thematic approach was used to classify and organize data according to key categories. The findings encompass direct quotes of women and narrated as without editing the grammar to avoid loss of its meaning. Quotes that best described the several categories and stated the frequently mentioned idea were chosen from several groups.

Ethical consideration

Before conducting the study, ethical approval was obtained from the ethical review committee of the College of Health Science, Wolaita Sodo University. Informed written consent was obtained from the study participants. The information obtained is kept confidential, and the collected data remained anonymous.

Sociodemographic characteristics of the participants

We carried out ten in-depth interviews among mothers who underwent early removal of long-acting family planning methods. All study participants were married. The majority of participants were protestant in religion. In terms of age, the participants were between 25-32 years old, and the mean age was 29.10+ (3.01 The majority of the participants (8 out of 10) were government employees, and 2 out of 10 were housewives. Half of all study participants were diploma holders (5 out of 10) (Table 1).

Table 1: Sociodemographic characteristics of women who underwent early removal of long-acting family planning methods in Bedesa town, Wolaita Zone, 2020.

Code	Age	Religion	Ethnicity	Educational status	Marital status	Occupation
IDI1	25	Protestant	Wolaita	Diploma	Married	Health informatics technician
IDI2	32	Protestant	Wolaita	Diploma	Married	government employee
IDI3	32	protestant	Wolaita	2 nd cycle	Married	Home manager
IDI4	25	protestant	Wolaita	BSC	Married	Teacher
IDI5	28	Protestant	Wolaita	Diploma	Married	Runner
IDI6	30	Protestant	Wolaita	2^nd cycle	Married	Merchant
IDI7	25	Orthodox	Wolaita	High school	Married	Home manager
IDI8	30	Protestant	Wolaita	Digree	Married	Midwives
IDI9	32	Protestant	Wolaita	Diploma	Married	Government
IDI10	32	Protestant	Wolaita	Diploma	Married	Government

User experience on contraceptive use

The majority of participants sufficiently explained their lived experience of contraceptive use. The most commonly mentioned experiences were types of contraceptive methods used, duration of using contraceptives and decisions for changing from one family planning method to the other. They also said that long-term use resulted in some problems with their health status.

“…Before I gave my first birth, I had been using depo. I used Jadelle after the second child. But Jadelle was removed because of side effects, and then I switched Jadelle to depo.” (IDI2)

Most women perceived that they regained their health immediately after removal of the long-acting contraceptive method. Furthermore, most study participants diverted their attention to short-acting contraceptives, mainly Depo-Provera.

“…After removal of Implanon, I regained my health and peaceful life. I have changed to Depo Provera, and I have been comfortable with depo. ” (IDI₁₀)

“… After removal of Implanon, the bleeding was not improved, and I went to the health center, and they removed it. However, the bleeding remained without showing any improvement. ” (IDI₇)

Some participants had fear of procedures during insertion and removal of long-acting family planning. Delayed fertility after removal of long-acting was another frequently stated fear by the clients. Some of them perceived that these contraceptive methods require eating special food and drinks. Some concerns of women regarding long-acting family planning methods were fear of death and paralysis, which causes medical illness and discomfort during sex.

“I feared using loop because of the information that was circulating in the community… mothers who used loop as birth control developed paralysis…. which refrained me from using it (IDI 1)”.

“Implant can move in your body from arm to leg, it can stab you, and you ’can’t work while the implant is in your arm. It is painful on insertion and removal and challenging to do hard works such as cooking food and washing clothes. Health workers are not interested in removal within six months after insertion”. (IDI 10)

“IUD is not good during sex. It can be lost in the body and may cause foul smelling vaginal discharge”. (IDI 6)

Reasons for early removal of long-acting family planning methods

The majority of participants mentioned that the side effects of the method were the main reason for early removal. There are different side effects mentioned for early removal, of which the frequently mentioned were heavy and irregular menses, weight loss, and dizziness. The other mentioned side effects were crampy abdominal pain, skin discoloration, itching, behavioral change, numbness, burning sensation on micturation, malaisma, headache, sleep disturbance, amenorrhea, delayed fertility, dysmenorrhea, frequent hunger, thirst, weakness, difficulty walking, and activity intolerance.

“…I decided to discontinue early because of heavy and irregular menses and weight loss. The bleeding stayed for one to two months. I also had skin discoloration and itchy skin” (IDI₁₀)

“…Implanon was inserted for 3 years, but it was kept only for 7 months. Because I was not comfortable, my facial skin color was changed, and black patches such as melasma appeared on my face. In addition, there was a movement in my abdomen like baby kicking during pregnancy, persistent neck pain, and absence of menses.” (IDI₁)

Almost all clients received counseling services by the health care provider. However, some of them mentioned that the counseling service was not adequate.

“Health workers gave me a counseling service before inserting Implanon. However, they didn’t inform me in detail about the benefits and risks of Implanon.” (IDI3)

“The health care providers informed me that an implant is more advantageous than injectable. Injectables do have an effect on bone damage, cause weight gain and contain additives. Pills are also full of additives, which may lead to gastritis.” (IDI₅).

Male involvement in contraceptive use and sharing responsibilities in reproductive life is essential. However, there was no consensus about the role of husbands in contraceptive decision making and use. Some women mentioned good support from their husbands for contraceptive use:

“…I stopped the injectable to get pregnant due to the influence made by my husband and few neighbors. Following the cessation of the injectable, I was on normal menstrual period for one year and half. Finally, I got pregnant and faced no problem during the whole pregnancy period until I gave birth at the health center.” (IDI₇₎

Another woman pointed out that the husband’s disapproval was one of the reasons for the early removal of Implanon “… My intention is to use Implanon for 3 years; however, my husband was against my intention. He even fought with me and bitten my hands.” (IDI₁₀)

Seeking more children was also found to be the other reason for the early removal of long-acting family planning methods. The majority of women desired two to three children. However, some of them desired more than five children

“…. Even though I took Implanon according to my personal choice and voluntary base, I have removed it because of seeking more children.” (IDI₂)

Participant suggestion and future plan

Most mothers identified different sorts of opinion regarding their future plan on family methods. The most frequently mentioned suggestions were to choose family planning methods without the influence of health professionals and to delay contraceptive use until the first child delivery.

“…information regarding family planning needs adequate counseling. However, health professionals do not provide adequate information. Most of the time, mothers obtain information from neighbours and become worried. ” (IDI₁₀)

“…I visited health facility three months after Implanon insertion to take Implanon off, but the health professional did not agree to remove it before six months.” (IDI₈)

This study identified side effects of long acting family planning methods as the main reason for the early removal which is consistent with other studies [8, 10-17]. The most frequently mentioned side effects were heavy and irregular menses, weight change, and dizziness. This finding is similar to studies conducted in Ethiopia and other low-income countries [8, 12, 15]. The reason for discontinuation may be due to inadequate counseling and lack of support from health care providers. This study also found that desiring more children was recognized as one of the common reasons for the early removal of long-acting family planning methods, which agrees with other similar studies [18-21]. Similarly, another study conducted in southern Nigeria showed that looking for more children causes a high rate of early removal of Implanon [22].

In this study, husband involvement was very important to use long-acting contraceptive use and to obtain a planned family size. This finding is consistent with the study conducted in Indonesia that husbands support the utilization of long-acting contraceptive methods [23, 24]. In contrast, another study showed that there is no relation with contraceptive use continuation and husband support[25].

Some participants believed that the implant could move freely in the body and get lost, and they also thought that implant and IUCD cause illness. The result of this study is consistent with the study conducted in the Wolaita Zone, Southern Ethiopia [26]. This might be due to the presence of rumors circulating in the community regarding long-acting family planning methods.

Our study explored problems with the health care providers’ counseling process. Another study also showed that the counseling was not enough and health care providers did not to allow clients to discuss their concerns freely [7]. This might also be a reason for the early removal of long-acting family planning methods.

According to the findings of current study most of the participants had information about family planning methods, which is consistent with similar research conducted in Arba Minch town[6]. However, the findings of demographic and health surveys of Ethiopia showed that women of reproductive age know less information on family planning methods[27, 28]. The possible reason for these differences could be the frequent promotion or advertisement of the methods by various stakeholders. The findings of this study also showed that a low proportion of respondents had awareness of permanent methods. Our findings were also substantiated by another study from Adigrat town [29] and Nekemte town[30].

Most participants mentioned side effects, wrong myths and misconceptions about long-acting family methods and desired to have family size as the main reason for the early removal of long-acting family planning methods. In addition, husband opposition and inadequate counseling were found to be other reasons for the early removal. Therefore, health professionals should provide adequate counseling to change the myths and misconceptions of clients on long-acting family planning methods.

EDHS: Ethiopian Demographic Health Survey, FMOH: Federal Ministry of Health, IDI: Indepth Interview, LAFP: Long acting Family Planning

Ethics approval and consent to participate:

Not applicable. The minimum age of participants was 25 years of age.Therefore, there is no need to obtain written informed consent for participation from parent or guardian.

Consent for publication:

Not applicable

Availability of data and materials

Data were uploaded as supporting files in the manuscript tracking system.

Funding:

Not applicable

Competing interest:

The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest.

Author’s contribution:

AA, MS, LK, MW, HC, and KS were involved in conceptualization and formal data curation analysis. Acquisition, investigation, methodology, software supervision validation visualization writing original draft writing review and editing.

TT, KT, MA, GM, and ZZ were involved in data curation, formal analysis, funding acquisition, investigation, project administration, resources, supervision, validation, visualization, writing original draft, writing review, and editing. All Authors read and approved the manuscript.

Acknowledgment:

Fristly, we would like to acknowledge Hepi Project University for providing materials used for the work. Then,we would like to thanks research square for reposting our edited manuscript on research square

Royston E, Armstrong S, Organization WH: Preventing maternal deaths: World Health Organization; 1989.
Kesetebirhan A: National Guideline for Family Planning Services in Ethiopia. Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia, Ministry of Health 2011.
Creanga AA, Gillespie D, Karklins S, Tsui AO: Low use of contraception among poor women in Africa: an equity issue. Bulletin of the World Health Organization 2011, 89:258-266.
Hancock NL, Stuart GS, Tang JH, Chibwesha CJ, Stringer JS, Chi BH: Renewing focus on family planning service quality globally. Contraception and reproductive medicine 2016, 1(1):10.
Bongaarts J, Cleland J, Townsend JW, Bertrand JT, Gupta MD: Family planning programs for the 21st century. New York: Population Council 2012:21.
Utaile MM, Debere MK, Nida ET, Boneya DJ, Ergano AT: A qualitative study on reasons for early removal of Implanon among users in Arba Minch town, Gamo Goffa zone, South Ethiopia: a phenomenological approach. BMC Women's Health 2020, 20(1):1-7.
McDowel M: A MIXED-METHODS STUDY OF FACTORS ASSOCIATED WITH IMPLANON REMOVAL IN ETHIOPIA. In.; 2017.
Utaile MM, Debere MK, Nida ET, Boneya DJ, Ergano AT: A qualitative study on reasons for early removal of Implanon among users in Arba Minch town, Gamo Goffa zone, South Ethiopia: a phenomenological approach. BMC Womens Health 2020, 20(1):2.
Gebremariam A, Addissie A: Knowledge and perception on long acting and permanent contraceptive methods in Adigrat town, Tigray, northern Ethiopia: a qualitative study. International journal of family medicine 2014, 2014.
Ethiopia Csao: EFDRE. ETHIOPIA Demographic and Health Survey 2016 Key Indicators Report. In. Edited by CSAE; 2016.
Aminu MB, Dattijo LM, Shehu AM, Kadas SA, Chama CM: Factors responsible for discontinuation of long-term reversible contraceptives in a tertiary facility in Northeastern Nigeria. Port Harcourt Medical Journal 2019, 13(2):67.
Nageso A, Gebretsadik A: Discontinuation rate of Implanon and its associated factors among women who ever used Implanon in Dale District, Southern Ethiopia. BMC Womens Health 2018, 18(1):189.
Tadesse A, Kondale M, Agedew E, Gebremeskel F, Boti N, Oumer B: Determinant of Implanon discontinuation among women who ever used Implanon in Diguna Fango District, Wolayita zone, southern Ethiopia: a community based case control study. International journal of reproductive medicine 2017, 2017.
Adeagbo O, Mullick S, Pillay D, Chersich M, Morroni C, Naidoo N, Pleaner M, Rees H: Uptake and early removals of Implanon NXT in South Africa: Perceptions and attitudes of healthcare workers. South African Medical Journal 2017, 107(10).
Staveteig S, Mallick L, Winter R: Uptake and discontinuation of long-acting reversible contraceptives (LARCs) in low-income countries. 2015.
Burusie A: Reasons for Premature Removal of Implanon among Users in Arsi Zone, Oromia Region, Ethiopia, 2013. Reproductive System & Sexual Disorders 2015, 04(01).
Birhane K, Hagos S, Fantahun M: Early discontinuation of implanon and its associated factors among women who ever used implanon in Ofla District, Tigray, Northern Ethiopia. International Journal of Pharma Sciences and Research 2015, 6(3):8.
Mesfin Mamo Utaile1* MKD, Etsehiwot Tilahun Nida2, Dube Jara Boneya3 and Amsale Tekle Ergano4: A qualitative study on reasons for early removal of Implanon among users in Arba Minch town, Gamo Goffa zone, South Ethiopia: a phenomenological approach BMC Women's Health 2020, 20(2 ):4-7.
Kalayu Birhane SG: Early discontinuation of implanon and its associated factors among womenwho ever used implanon in Ofla District, Tigray, Northern Ethiopia. International Journal of Pharma Sciences and Research (IJPSR) 2015, 6 (3):544-551.
Alem Gebremariam AA: intention to use long acting and permanent contrceptive methods and factors affecting it among married women in Adigrat twon ,Tigray, Notrhen Ethiopia. BMC Reproductive health 2014, 11(24).
Hbtamu Zerihun1 AB, Alehengn Worku3, Eyasu Desta 3, HailemariamTafesse2 ,Hika Dinss4a,Ashenafi Asmelash 5, Tadele Hailu6, Tekalihn Dmena6, , Mirgesa Kaba7, Mitike Molla7, Eshetu Girma7 , Mulugeta Tamire 7 Implanon removal experience of women in Butajia, ethiopia. EthipJhealth Dev 2015, 29(3):177-180.
Ojule JD OE, Enyindah CE.: Experience with Implanon in southern Nigeria J Med Med Sci 2012, 3(11):710–714.
Bewket Zeleke L, Gella MM, Almaw Derseh H, Alemu AA, Abebe Kassahun E, Gelaw KA: Utilization of Long-Acting Contraceptive Methods and Associated Factors among Female Health Care Providers in East Gojjam Zone, Northwest Ethiopia, in 2018. BioMed research international 2019, 2019:5850629.
Mukamuyango J, Ingabire R, Parker R, Nyombayire J, Easter SR, Wall KM, Tichacek A, Nyirazinyoye L, Kaslow N, Allen S et al: Motivational interviewing to promote long-acting reversible contraception among Rwandan couples wishing to prevent or delay pregnancy. American journal of obstetrics and gynecology 2019.
Harzif AK, Mariana A, Malik DM, Silvia M, Lovita BT: Factors associated with the utilization of long-acting reversible contraceptives among family planning clients at the Pameungpeuk Rural Hospital, Indonesia. F1000Research 2018, 7:1891.
Meskele M, Mekonnen W: Factors affecting women’s intention to use long acting and permanent contraceptive methods in Wolaita Zone, Southern Ethiopia: A cross-sectional study. BMC women's health 2014, 14(1):109.
Gebremedhin AY, Kebede Y, Gelagay AA, Habitu YA: Family planning use and its associated factors among women in the extended postpartum period in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. Contraception and reproductive medicine 2018, 3(1):1.
Tarekegn SM, Lieberman LS, Giedraitis V: Determinants of maternal health service utilization in Ethiopia: analysis of the 2011 Ethiopian Demographic and Health Survey. BMC pregnancy and childbirth 2014, 14(1):161.
Gebremariam A, Addissie A: Intention to use long acting and permanent contraceptive methods and factors affecting it among married women in Adigrat town, Tigray, Northern Ethiopia. Reproductive health 2014, 11(1):24.
Hambissa G, Sena L, Hiko D, Merga H: Intention to Use Long Acting and Permanent Contraceptives Methods and Associated Factors among Family Planning Clients in West Ethiopia. Fam Med Med Sci Res 2018, 7(228):2.

Download PDF

Version 1

posted

You are reading this latest preprint version

Lived experience of women who underwent early removal of long-acting Contraceptive Methods: A phenomenological study

Status:

Version 1

Abstract

Background

Methods

Results

Discussion

Conclusion

Abbreviations

Declarations

Ethics approval and consent to participate:

Consent for publication:

Availability of data and materials

Funding:

Competing interest:

Author’s contribution:

Acknowledgment:

References

Status:

Version 1