3.1. Structural analysis of PW and NW NCs
Fig. 2 shows the X-ray diffraction pattern of PW and NW NCs. Eight characteristic peaks indexed to (002) (110) (220) (222) (260) (262) (440) (442) planes were observed for PW, with a high crystalline quality, which well-matched with standard JCPDS No: 72-0199 (face-centered cubic). The presence of NiWO4/WO3 was in good agreement with the standard JCPDS No: 15-0755 (monoclinic) and 72-0199 (orthorhombic). This result is astonishing since Ni2+ (0.69A) has a layer ionic radius concerning W6+ (0.60A) [12,13] and thereby substitution of Ni ions in W ions considerably increases the lattice constant. Using the Scherrer formula the average crystallite size for PW and NW NCs were calculated as 22-17nm. Due to the “mutual protective effect” between NiWO4/WO3 the crystallite size decreases and the microstrain (𝜀) increases with the increasing concentration of Ni in WO3 [14]. The formation of oxygen vacancies in WO3.H2O upon Ni doping causes lattice distortion and decreases interplanar spacing. Because of the stoichiometric composition of doping, the peak has shifted towards the higher angle of diffraction for the NW3 and NW4 composite. This effect is mainly due to the difference in ionic radii between PW and NW NCs [15,16]. The decrease in crystallite size was observed with an increase in the W% of Ni. This is because of the reduction in the diffusion rate of NW NCs and also due to the distortion in the PW lattice by foreign impurities [17]. Moreover, the difference in the crystallite size can be attributed to the pH of the solution, solvent content, the solubility of the deposit, adhesion to the substrate, etc [2, 18]. This is well supported by the larger average values of dislocation density (𝛿) and microstrain (𝜀) which also increases the defect in the NW NCs and it may enhance the conductivity and photocatalytic activity in NW NCs [19,20].
Table 1. Structural parameters calculated for PW and NW NCs
Samples
|
Crystalline Size (D) [nm]
|
Micro strain (ε) × 10−3 [lines−2 m−4]
|
Dislocation density
(δ) ×10 - 14
[lines cm−2]
|
Stacking fault
(SF) × 10−2
|
PW
|
38.959
|
0.0789
|
1.053
|
0.277
|
NW1
|
20.556
|
0.196
|
4.064
|
0.750
|
NW2
|
26.437
|
0.148
|
2.114
|
0.429
|
NW3
|
23.632
|
0.191
|
4.038
|
0.543
|
NW4
|
17.610
|
0.218
|
4.406
|
0.675
|
3.2. FTIR spectral analysis of PW and NW NCs
Fig.3 represents FTIR spectra of PW and NW NPs. The band around 3000-3500cm-1 and 1600 - 1650 cm-1 attributed to O-H stretching vibrations [21, 22]. The band observed from 800- 500 cm-1 was due to W–O–O–W stretching vibration. The band at 780 cm-1 corresponds to Ni-O stretching [23]. The FTIR investigation confirms that PW nanoplates have a lower amount of surface OH groups than NW4 NCs. The photocatalytic activity has improved by the charge transfer of photo-generated holes of the hydroxyl group in the surface [24].
3. 3 Tauc plot of PW and NW NCs
In Fig.4, the bandgap (Eg) value was calculated using the Tauc plot for the PW and NW NCs from the given relation, From Fig.4 the bandgap values were found in the range of 2.9eV to 2.5eV. The narrowing of the bandgap is due to the influence of electron transition between the valence and conduction bands [25]. Moreover, decreasing the optical band gap of higher concentrations of Ni in NW4 suggested that the presence of Ni strongly influenced the optical parameters of the NW composites. The reduction in Eg which forms an acceptor level led to redshift denotes the localized nature of Ni species in PW lattice contributing to the creation of surface oxygen vacancies [26,27].
3.4. FE-SEM analysis of PW and NW NC
Fig.5 shows FE-SEM images of PW are nanoplate-like structures and NWNCs are nanoflake structures. Due to the increase in the concentration of Ni, plate-like structures are transformed into agglomerated nanoflakes. Compared to plate-like structures, nanoflakes have a large surface area which results in enhanced dye absorption and hence facilitates an enhanced photocurrent [28]. The edges of NW4 nanoflakes are curly and twisted which form a porous structure with each other. This porous structure will help to absorb the dye and enhance photocatalytic activity [29].
3.5 DC electrical conductivity
The dc electrical conductivity (σdc) and activation energy (Ea) was calculated by using following relation
σdc = t/RA (2)
Ea = slope value × (KB / e) eV (3)
Where t is the thickness of the interfacial layer, R is the series resistance of the structure and A is the rectifier contact area, KB is the Boltzmann constant and V is the applied voltage.
The calculated conductivity is found to vary in the range (2.5x10-8eV) to (3.3x10-7eV) for different concentrations listed in Table 2. The NW4 NCs showed maximum conductivity, 3.3x10-7 eV. Due to the oxygen vacancies in the grown semiconducting nature of the NCs, the conductivity reaches maximum. [30]. As the Ni concentration increases, the average activation energy values decrease suggesting the fact that the Ni atom could have created some impurities in the bandgap of NiWO4/WO3 NCs. Moreover, the increase in the oxygen vacancies is mainly due to the presence of Ni clusters in the WO3 lattice [31]. Similar behavior of decreasing Ea values with increasing dopant concentration was reported [32,33]. The above results confirm the stability of PW and NW NCs and their employability in optoelectronics devices.
Table.2.The variation of average conductivity and activation energy of PW and NW NCs thin film
Samples
|
Avg. Conductivity σ(=1/ρ) (S/cm)
|
Avg. Activation energy (eV)
|
PW
|
2.49647 X 10-8
|
0.16909
|
NW1
|
3.47219 X 10-8
|
0.12245
|
NW2
|
1.34253 X 10-7
|
0.09941
|
NW3
|
2.03321 X 10-7
|
0.09451
|
NW4
|
3.33903 X 10-7
|
0.08824
|
3.6 Photoluminescence
The PL spectrum is a vital technique to study the surface processes involving photogenerated electron-hole pairs. This study has been widely used to find out the efficiency of charge carrier trapping, migration, and to understand the pairs of electron-hole in semiconductors. In Fig. 7, the higher intensity of the green emission peak was observed at 529nm and 532 nm. The wider and higher intensities are usually assigned to the deep level of emissions due to oxygen vacancies, and anionic or cationic interstitial defects for NW NCs [34, 35]. Higher intensity of NW4 NCs leads to a lower recombination rate of photo-generated electrons and holes [36]. In which the optical response of the material is largely determined by its underlying electronic properties that are closely related to its chemical, atomic arrangement, and physical dimension for nanometer-sized materials. It’s also noted that the PL emission peak slightly shifts towards a higher wavelength (redshift). This may be due to the increase in Ni3+ ions which act as a conducting center and reduces the Eg [27]. From the PL emission spectra, the addition of NW4 NCs indicates an effective carrier extraction and reduced recombination [37]. Thus it will help to improve JSC and the performance of DSSC. Moreover, the grain size of the DSSC could make an important attribution to PL spectra and the device performance.
3.7 Photocatalytic activity
Fig .8 shows the rate of decomposition of methyl blue by PW and NW4 NCs under visible light irradiation. Pseudo-first-order rate constant reaction: ln (A0/At) = Kapp t was employed to study the degradation, where At is the absorbance of MB at time t, Ao is the absorbance value at t=0 and k is the pseudo-first-order rate constant. NW4 NCs photocatalyst exhibited a high response in the visible light region. In general, the photocatalytic efficiency depends on the consequence of photo-generated hole-electron pairs in the photocatalytic process of semiconductors under light irradiation [38]. The photo-generated electrons in CB of NW4 NCs can quickly retransfer to the surface to participate in the photocatalytic reaction, thus decrease the recombination probability of photo-generated electrons and holes, suggesting that the introduction of Ni ions into WO3 can induce little more trap-state, which can further reduce the recombination rate [39]. The photo-generated electrons and holes react with the surface substances adsorbed, O2, OH, etc to form reactive species such as O2, OH* (hydroxyl radical), which is major oxidative species for the decomposition of organic pollutants [40]. Then the oxidative species degrade the organic pollutant MB into small molecules like CO2, H2O, etc. To prevent the recombination of photo-induced electron-hole pairs, structure, size, and Eg play an important role [27]. The Kapp value of PW and NW4 NCs is 0.02249 and 0.02266 respectively. Due to the larger Eg, PW shows a less degradation rate constant. This was improved with narrow Eg of NW4 NCs, which supports the better photocatalytic activity. Moreover, the substitution of Ni reduces the recombination rate of the electron-hole pair due to charge compensation between Ni and W. This may be due to the creation of oxygen vacancies that can act as oxidizing species in enhancing photocatalytic activity [26].
3.8 Photovoltaic performance of DSSCs
The light-harvesting activity of a dye molecule is a key parameter that determines the ability of solar energy capture and in turn affects the photocurrent generated by solar cells.
FF = (Jmax×Vmax) / (Jsc×Voc) (4)
η(%) = ((FF × Jsc × Voc) / (Pin) ) × 100 (5)
Fig.9 shows the J-V characteristic curve of the DSSCs under simulated sunlight illumination. Their corresponding photovoltaic parameters were calculated and given in Table 3. From Table 1 it was obvious that the short circuit current density (Jsc), the open-circuit voltages (Voc), Fill factor (FF) and the photo electrolytic cell efficiency (h), enhanced gradually with an increase in Ni content. The photovoltaic parameters reveal that the cell efficiencies increased from 2.48% to 3.49% for PW to NW4.
Table. 3 Photovoltaic parameters of the synthesized sample.
Samples
|
Jsc
(mA/cm2)
|
Voc
|
FF
|
Ƞ
(%)
|
PW
|
7.4
|
0.8
|
0.42
|
2.48
|
NW1
|
7.3
|
0.8
|
0.49
|
2.91
|
NW2
|
7.3
|
0.8
|
0.51
|
2.94
|
NW3
|
7.5
|
0.8
|
0.55
|
3.30
|
NW4
|
7.5
|
0.8
|
0.58
|
3.49
|
In addition, reduced recombination of NW NCs acts as good electron transfer. The photoanode generates small crystallites on the surface of the NCs, thereby increasing the adsorption of dye molecules and leading to the generation of more photoelectrons and light-harvesting- capacity [41]. The enhanced light absorption of NW4 electrode-based DSSC to the visible region is due to Ni doping, wherein JSC and FF of NW4 electrode get increased [41]. Here improved Jsc is due to the higher chemical capacitance of NW4 and higher FF reveals reduced recombination kinetics in NW-based DSSCs [42]. The adsorption of carboxyl groups in the N719 dye molecule leads to increased dye loading capacity and enhanced cell performance [43]. NW4 NCs are responsible for better photovoltaic properties for lower recombination rate, superior light-harvesting capability, surface area prolonged charge transport pathway-based device [15]. The increment in Ni concentration improves the electrochemical performance of PW, which confirms the feasibility of their role in DSSC. The maximum PCE obtained for NW4 DSSC is 3.49% which may be due to its higher incorporation of Ni concentration in PW.