This study explored socio-demographic, socioeconomic, behavioural, psychosocial, and environmental determinants of adolescent PA and examined whether the determinants of PA varied according to the intersection of gender and family SES.
Our findings for socio-demographic and -economic determinants revealed that female gender, older age, lower family SES, lower educational levels and immigrant backgrounds were all associated with lower PA. These results support previous findings linking lower PA in adolescents to female gender, older age, immigrant backgrounds, lower family SES and lower education (8, 12, 26, 43). Several mechanisms could explain these associations. For example, research shows that self-efficacy and social support for PA are key mediators of the relationships between PA and both income and educational level (43). Similarly, gender discrepancies in PA can be partially attributed to motivation. A recent study found that body image was a more important motivation for regular PA for female adolescents than males, whereas the fun of physical exertion was a primary motivation for PA in more males than females (24). Female adolescents also seem less inclined to engage in recreational PA with peers after school, such as in organized sports clubs, largely accounting for PA gender differences (44).
Amongst behavioural determinants, daily smoking, cannabis use, risk of problematic gaming and social media use, as well as lack of daily consumption of fruit, vegetables, water and breakfast were all associated with lower PA. These findings are in line with the evidence that adolescent PA are associated with other health behaviours, such as smoking (14), and that motivational and self-regulatory processes leading to engagement in one’s health behaviour may “spill-over” into another (45, 46). Such psychosocial factors are also likely confounders, given that higher self-efficacy, social support or self-regulatory capacity are all related to increased PA (47–50), but also predict, for example, greater vegetable consumptions (48, 51) or less smoking (52, 53). Our findings support the evidence linking problematic social media use or gaming to decreased PA (15, 16). Although confounding variables could partially explain this association, problematic social media use and gaming may have a more direct negative effect on PA, since they can increase sedentary behaviour and substitute PA in the adolescent’s routine (54–56).
For psychosocial determinants, poorer self-perceived health, low peer social support and weak connection with the neighbourhood were associated with lower PA. In line with the evidence from a systematic review (57), our findings revealed that poor self-perceived health was associated with lower PA in adolescents. This study also found that peer social support was strongly associated to PA, which is consistent with evidence that peer social support is one of the most important predictors of adolescent’s PA (58).
Finally, for environmental determinants a weak connection with the neighbourhood was associated with lower PA, which is consistent with studies demonstrating a relationship between a neighbourhood’s social environment and adolescent PA (21, 59, 60). The strong social ties in one’s neighbourhood may influence adolescent’s PA through several stress-buffering, health-enhancing mechanisms, such as social norms, social support, self-efficacy, self-control, and increased contact with others (61, 62).
Although several similar epidemiological studies have explored determinants of PA in adolescents, few studies have explored how these determinants may vary according to the interplay of certain socio-demographic and -economic characteristics. Intersectionality theory emphasizes that people’s resources, experiences and identities are not only shaped by several individual characteristics, such as gender and SES, but also by the unique interplay of these characteristics (63). From the lens of intersectionality, low SES and female gender are associated with vulnerabilities for lower PA which may not be separate, but rather interactive and multiplicative in their effects (64). Our findings indicated that the effects of certain determinants on PA was influenced by the intersection of gender and family SES, which may reflect the unique needs and barriers for PA in subgroups with compounding vulnerabilities.
While most behaviours were consistently related to PA across gender or family SES in our sample, our findings showed that cannabis use was only associated with less PA amongst adolescents from low-SES. This may reflect the role of possible confounders, such as low self-control or low parental social support, which may render adolescents with low-SES more vulnerable to both early cannabis use and low levels of PA (19, 53, 65–68). Future research is needed to examine the causality of the relationship between early cannabis use and adolescent PA, while accounting for the role of potential confounders.
Furthermore, in our sample, poor perceived health was associated with decreased levels of PA in adolescents from moderate- or high-SES families, but not for adolescents from low-SES families. One possible explanation for this finding is that adolescents from low-SES households may have different conceptions of health, in which PA may be less strongly linked to health perceptions. In support of this notion, research has demonstrated that associations with self-perceived health were considerably different between native Dutch individuals and ethnic minorities (69), who are typically of lower SES (70). These findings suggest that the meaning attached to the single-item question assessing self-perceived health may differ between ethnic and SES groups.
Our findings also revealed that, while peer social support was a significant predictor of PA in all groups, it exerted the strongest effects on the PA of male adolescents from low-SES families, suggesting that peer social support may be particularly important for this subgroup. Research has found that children from high/middle SES schools report engaging in more family-based activities and organized sports than adolescents from low-SES schools (71). In contrast, since costs are an important barrier for PA in adolescents from low-SES schools, this group reports engaging in more unstructured “free-play”, which is more influenced by peer social support (71). Another study has shown that parental social support, an important predictor of adolescents’ PA (19), is lower in low-SES adolescents than in high-SES adolescents (72). Given that other forms of social support for PA may be lacking in their home environment and that there are limited opportunities for family-based activities or organized sports, peer social support may be particularly important for promoting PA in adolescents from low-SES families.
Importantly, the three-way interaction with family SES and gender also suggested that, amongst adolescents from low-SES families, peer social support was also more important for males than females. This finding is in line with another study showing that peer social support was an important determinant of PA in male adolescents, but not in females (28). These results may reflect previously discussed gender differences in motivation for PA. Given that fun of PA is a more prevalent motivation for PA in males than in females (24), and the fact that male adolescents are more likely to join sport clubs (44), it is plausible that peer social support has a stronger influence on the PA of male adolescents than females. The idea of "pick-up" games or neighbourhood activities may be more prevalent among males than females, and such activities may be more influenced by the social support of peers. Certain environmental factors, such as neighbourhood safety, may also limit the opportunities for outside play for females’ adolescents more than for males, particularly for those from low-SES families (73).
These findings emphasize the importance of exploring the intersections of socio-demographic and -economic factors when exploring the determinants of adolescents PA, since the interaction of these characteristics may give rise to unique experiences with different needs, barriers and facilitators for PA. By investigating intersectionality, public health professionals can develop more specific recommendations and interventions to promote adolescent’s PA based, for instance, on the interplay of gender and SES.
The strengths of this study included high participation rates and the systematic recruitment of a large sample of male and female adolescents from secondary schools, which ensured that our sample was representative of this target group and that our results can be generalized to other similar populations. Additionally, rather than exclusively focusing on cognitive factors typically researched in the context of PA, this study assessed correlates of PA from various domains, namely socio-demographic and -economic characteristics, psychosocial, behavioural and environmental determinants. Our results indicate that relevant determinants from these different domains are not completely independent, but rather “intersect” or interact with each other. Focusing exclusively on a single domain and overlooking important determinants of PA at different levels (e.g. sociodemographic or environmental) may thus lead to inaccurate conclusions. Therefore, the findings on this study emphasizes the need of a multivariate approach to understanding of factors associated with adolescent’s PA, as well as of how these determinants may vary according to socio-demographic and -economic characteristics. As suggested by intersectionality theory, gaining insight on how the influence of certain determinants on PA may vary, for instance, according to the adolescent’s gender or SES, can guide the tailoring of future interventions to address the specific needs of individuals.
Nevertheless, several limitations of the current study should be considered when interpreting the results. It is important to note that this study adopted a cross-sectional study design, thus causality cannot be inferred for the associations observed. Longitudinal study designs are needed to further examine the link between sociodemographic characteristics, determinants of PA, and adolescent’s PA in order to gain more insight into the causality of these relationships. This was an explorative study in which the effect of multiple potential determinants of PA and their interactions with socio-demographic and -economic factors (i.e. gender and family SES) were investigated. Hence, although the variables included were carefully selected by behavioural experts as potential predictors of adolescent’s PA prior to the start of the study, we recognize that multiple comparisons may have enhanced the chance of a type 1 error, which is a limitation of this study. Nonetheless, this explorative designed allowed us to explore potential differences in determinants of PA according to the intersection of gender and family SES, rather than examining these factors in isolation, which is an approach that has largely been overlooked. To guide the development of tailored PA interventions, further research is needed to replicate our findings and to continue investigating how the intersection of socio-demographic and -economic characteristics influences determinants of PA in adolescents.
Another limitation inherent to research based on population surveys was the use of self-report measures of PA. Although the survey incorporated a widely used and validated PA measure (32, 33), it is well established that self-report measures of PA are limited by recall difficulties, social desirability bias, and overestimation of PA levels, especially in adolescents (74, 75). Moreover, the single-item measure used assessed total levels of PA, which limited our ability to explore predictors of active-transport, recreational, and school-based PA separately. Future studies should collect data separately on these types of PA in order to explore the differential effects of various factors on certain types of PA. Despite the limitations of the self-report measures used, the current study was not only able to identify several determinants that are associated with total PA in adolescents, but also to gain insight on how the influence of these determinants vary according the intersection of gender and family SES.