Cochlear sensitivity, essential for communication and exploiting the acoustic environment, is due to the sensory-motor outer hair cells (OHCs) that operate in the structural scaffold of supporting cells and extracellular spaces in the cochlear organ of Corti (OoC). It is unclear whether supporting cells (e.g., Deiters cells [DCs] and outer pillar cells [OPCs]) control cochlear sensitivity in vivo. Here we employed optogenetics to measure in vivo sound-induced cochlear mechanical and electrical responses, and ex vivo light-induced DC electrical responses in the OoC of mice that conditionally expressed channelrhodopsins (ChR2) specifically in DCs and OPCs. Illumination activated a nonselective ChR2 cation conductance and depolarized the DCs. This transient action reversibly blocked continuous, normally occurring, minor adjustments of tone-evoked basilar membrane displacements, and OHC voltage responses to tones at and close to their characteristic frequency, and speeded recovery from temporary acoustic desensitization. This is the first direct evidence for the interdependency of the structural, mechanical, and electrochemical arrangement of OHCs and OoC supporting cells which together fine control cochlear sensitivity.