During the past several years, technological advancement of Evolut R was built on the well-established foundation of the CoreValve platform, fortified with lower delivery profile (14-16 French) to reduce vascular complications and alternative TAVR access necessity, enhanced Nitinol frame geometry to enable better housing inside the aortic root, and a complete recapturable platform that allows optimized implantation depth upon deployment. Our results support short-term efficacy and safety performance of the Evolut-R compare with the CoreValve. Evolut R significantly reduce 30-day composite safety endpoint, driven by numerically lower deaths, major stroke, life-threatening or disabling bleeding, and acute stage 2 or 3 kidney injury including renal replacement therapy.
The InLine sheath used in the Evolut R system has a lower profile (14-16 French) than CoreValve (18 French), which lowered the need for alternative TAVR access, which has historically been associated with inferior outcomes in patients undergoing TAVR, from 7.7–2.6%. Pre-dilatation was observed significantly more often in the CoreValve group, which may be responsible for longer procedure duration and increased contrast agent administration. The higher volume of contrast use is one of the underlying mechanisms leading to acute kidney injury which remains one of the strongest predictors of short- and long-term mortality after TAVR.
Valve malposition may still occur even after all necessary precautions have been taken, while prosthesis migration and embolization were associated with a four-fold higher mortality and three-fold higher stroke rate at 30 days12. Compared to CoreValve, a key feature of the Evolut-R is the option to fully recapture and to reposition the valve during deployment. There were 3 cases (2.6%) in the CoreValve treated patient requiring the implantation of a second valve, and one (0.9%) in the Evolut R group. In addition, the option to recapture allowed a less ventricular implantation depth, resulting in a numerically lower incidence of new pacemaker implantation and moderate PVL in the Evolut R recipients.
Left ventricular perforation is the most serious complications of TAVR, usually occurs as a direct trauma by the Amplatz Super Stiff guidewire, which was used exclusively for the deployment of CoreValve. Amplatz. Super Stiff guidewire are not designed for TAVR procedures and the operators must bend the wire to achieve the optimal shape to sit safely in the ventricle for TAVR, during which procedure the central core can be damaged or the desired shape may not be achieved, A pooled analysis of causes of perioperative mortality after TAVR (12 studies examining 1223 patients) showed that 10.1% of deaths at one month were due to pericardial tamponade while 39% of “in-lab” mortality was due to cardiac perforation causing pericardial tamponade13. Notably, the adoption of a dedicated pre-shaped Confida Brecker guidewire, features a continuous, tapered core and pre-shaped curve, in the Evolut R recipients reduce the risk of left ventricular perforation, which necessitated emergent cardiac surgery, from 5.1% in the CoreValve group to none in the Evolut R recipients.
The primary goal of TAVR is to achieve the maximum orifice area with a minimum flow velocity. Given severe prosthesis-patient mismatch (PPM) was associated with increased risk of 1-year mortality (hazard ratio: 1.19) and heart failure re-hospitalization (hazard ratio: 1.12) following TAVR in 62,125 patients enrolled in the STS/ACC TVT Registry14, there has been a concern regarding PPM in Asian patients with small aortic annulus. Studies in east Asian populations demonstrated Sapien 3 valve had smaller EOA (2.07 ± 0.61 vs. 1.70 ± 0.49 cm2, p < 0.001)15 and caused PPM about 1.92 times16 more than Sapien XT valve. Thus, TAVR with supra-annular self-expanding was associated with superior hemodynamic outcomes compared with balloon-expandable valves in patients with small aortic annulus. These findings pave the way for further trials regarding appropriate prosthesis selection for TAVR in patients with in East Asian population with small aortic annulus.