Over the years, there has been many debates about whether there are differences in semen quality between different regions. After the quantitative analysis of the correlation of semen quality in 667 sperm donors between the north and south of China, our data revealed that donors living in the north of China have significantly higher sperm concentration than those in the south of China (the median were 134, 125, P=0.015). Similarly, there were statistically significant differences in sperm concentration among men from different latitudes in China (P=0.04). Sperm concentration is an important parameter for semen, indicating level of male's fertility. Our results are the first to comprehensively describe differences in semen quality between the north and south of China, and regional differences in semen quality may have biological significance.
A representative study with a large number of healthy men from China showed that age-related changes were not found in sperm concentration among different age groups of Chinese men[17], consistent with a previous meta-analysis by a stronger methodology which found no relationship between male age and sperm concentration[18]. The same results showed that there were no significant differences between male age and sperm concentration in our research (P > 0.05).
According to relevant statistics, the distribution of Chinese population has undergone tremendous changes. In recent years, the population of the north has been on a decline, while the south shows an opposite trend[19], which was believed to be related to the migration caused by different distribution of regional economy[20]. As a result, larger population in the south contributes to its heavier level of pollution. Consistent with previous studies demonstrating the negative impact that pollution has on semen quality[21], we observed a higher concentration of sperm in the semen sampled from donors living in the north, in accordance with the milder pollution in the north. In addition, people tend to suffer from greater psychological burden in more densely populated areas. The association between mental stress and reduced semen quality was supported by a study that built a biological plausibility[22]. Under mental stress, the endocrine system of men is interrupted, which manifests as low levels of testosterone and luteinizing hormone and subsequently interferes with sperm production, thus resulting in decreased male fertility[23].Therefore, mental stress may also account for the regional differences in sperm concentration between the north and south of China. In summary, the influence of environmental factors and lifestyle on semen quality may be explained by the changes in fertility patterns brought about by migration[24].
In addition to the factors mentioned above, some other factors such as seasons, ethnic, dietary pattern and obesity may also affect semen quality.
In an assessment of male infertility data in the United States, compared with Asian men, the white men have higher sperm production but lower sperm concentration[25]. Because of conditions, only 5.6% of our sperm donors are from ethnic minorities, and the most of sperm donors are from Han ethnic group, With limited data, we were unable to assess whether the difference in semen quality between north and south China was related to ethnic.
In terms of diet, a cross-sectional study in Spain that assessed the relationship between dietary patterns and fertility had suggested that adherence to a healthy diet positively correlates with sperm concentration and sperm motility[26]. Different from the western diet pattern,the traditional Chinese diet is based on grains, and, due to the difference in latitude and climate, the southern people eat rice and the northern people eat flour. At present, there is no literature on the effect of rice and flour on semen quality. However, some tables made from reliable blood glucose index (GI) data sources found that sperm concentration was negatively correlated with the frequency and quantity of grain consumption[27], Because grains are rich in starch with high starch content. When dietary intake leads to an increase in blood sugar, hyperglycemia will increase the risk of inflammation, which will lead to a decline in male semen quality[28]. In summary, data on the relationship between diet and semen quality or male infertility factors are still limited. Additional prospective studies, including those exploring biological mechanisms, are needed to explain the relationship between dietary patterns and male fertility[29]. Therefore, how the difference in diet structure between the south and the north influences semen quality still needs further exploration.
in the matter of seasons, as was reported, the parameters such as sperm concentration and total sperm count collected by outdoor workers in summer were significantly lower than that from the same workers collected in winter[30]. While in another study, the effect of seasonal changes on semen quality could not be discovered. Some analysts speculate that the high temperatures may affect testicular spermatogenesis. However, the study conducted by Golher et al suggested that the sperm function parameters of crossbred bucks, which were reared in subtropical climate, did not show any difference in different seasons, which may be related to the advanced testicular temperature regulation mechanism in the body[31]. Our study did not record the seasons when volunteer donated their semen due to limited statistical conditions, but we will incorporate this factor into statistics in future studies.
As for obesity, reduced fertility in obese men is thought to be linked to changes in the levels of hormones that form sperm[32]. Since the obese sperm donors were excluded from the current study, our results are thus independent of the influence of obesity. It is worth mentioning that compared with the sperm donors in the south, the average BMI of the sperm donors in the north is significantly higher (P = 0.002). We also noted that previous studies had indicated differences in the distribution of BMI between adolescents in the north and the south of China. Adolescents in the north of China generally have a bulky figure, a phenomenon that is independent of the level of socio-economic development[33]. Some studies believe that the adaptation of the human body to the surrounding environment may cause regional differences of human growth and development[34]. Moreover, sufficient sunshine, low annual average temperature and observable seasonal temperature variability in the north of China are all beneficial to body fat accumulation of individuals[35], which may be the reason for higher BMI of sperm donors in the north of china.
Although the reason for the geographical variation of semen quality is not yet clear, lifestyle and environmental factors are supposed to be the causes[36]. Specifically, we suppose that environmental pollution and mental stress due to increased population may be the main factors in the difference.
Limitations
This study is only a preliminary study on the regional differences in semen quality of sperm donors between the north and south of china. Future investigations are still needed to further validate the geographic variations in larger regions with a more accurate study design to address the issues listed above.