Retrospective cohort (n=77)
From our CTC database with 839 patients with MBC and at least one CTC count, 77 (9.1%) patients could be identified in accordance with the limited in- and exclusion criteria. Clinical details are summarized in Table 2. Median age was 63 years (range: 33-91). At the time of this analysis, all 77 patients have died from MBC. Survival is counted in elapsed days since the blood sample collection for CTC enumeration. Median overall survival is 178 days (15-3120). Although heterogeneous, this is overall a cohort with poor prognosis. Twenty five (32.5%) patients had died within three months of study entry.
Median CTC count was 53/7.5 mL (range: 0-100.000/7.5 mL). Only 14 of the 77 patients (18%) had a CTC count lower than 5 CTC/7.5mL.
All 77 patient had at least one routine coagulation test result outside the limits of normal.
In total 13 patients (16.8%) were diagnosed with abnormalities compatible with overt DIC.
Only 7 and 5 patients had respectively an increased aPTT or PTT. No significant association between aPTT or PTT with either CTC, platelet count or D-dimers could be identified.
Correlation between CTC and OS
The prognostic significance for overall survival of CTC count at time of progression ( < or ≥ 5 CTC /7.5mL) was confirmed (Figure 1). Median OS was respectively 150 days versus 1155 days with a logrank HR of 2.826 (p< 0.0001) (Figure 1A).
Correlation between D-dim and OS
The levels of D-dimer ranged between 161 and 77735 ng/mL with a median of 2145 ng/mL. Linear regression of the ln value of D-dimers with OS was statistically significant (p<0.0001, R2 =0.4625). (Figure 1B1).
Median OS according to the median D-dim was 93 days versus 450 days with a logrank HR of 2.586 (1.574-4.247) (p<0.0001) (Figure 1B2).
Correlation between CTC as a continuous variable and D-dim level
In this cohort a striking linear correlation exist between CTC enumeration and ln D-dimer level (p< 0.0001; R2 0.3215) (Figure 1C).
Correlation between CTC and platelet count (PLT).
The average platelet number varied between 24 and 592.109/mL with a median value of 206. The PLT level was correlated with the ln CTC level ( p< 0.0009, R2 0.167) (Figure 1D).
Correlation between D-dim and PLT
Platelet count is negatively correlated with D-dim level ( p<0.016) (Fig 1E).
Univariate and Multivariate analysis for OS
In the univariate analysis, presence of visceral disease, number of lines of chemotherapy (0 vs 1 vs 2+), ln CTC, CTC at baseline, CTC ≥ 5 , the ln D-dimers, platelet count and serum LDH were significantly associated with overall survival. ER status, HER2 status, TN disease, age, and fibrinogen level were not.
In multivariate analysis only CTC ≥ 5 at baseline, ln D-dimers, lines of chemotherapy 0-1 vs 2+) and presence of visceral disease were associated with OS.
Clinical course of two patients from cohort 1 with overt DIC
Patient 1
A 43 year old patient was diagnosed in 04/2009 with stage IV, bone-only, triple positive IDA (ER+/PgR+/HER2+). She was consecutively treated with trastuzumab and paclitaxel, trastuzumab with letrozole, ado-trastuzumab, and before admission with trastuzumab and vinorelbine. On December 3, 2013 she was admitted with epistaxis and disorientation. She suffered from severe thrombocytopenia (28.109/mL) , anemia (7.0 gr/dL), with low fibrinogen and high D-dimers. CT-scan showed a spontaneous subdural hematoma, that was surgically relieved. Subsequent results showed bone only disease, with extreme high CTC count > 100.000/ 7.5 mL, D-dimers 77735 ng/mL, increasing bilirubin, presence of schistocytes, unmeasurable haptoglobin and absent ADAMTS13 inhibitor. Time course of the results between December 12 and 19 is shown in Figure 2. Patient succumbed of her disease on the 19th of December.
Patient 2
A 32 year old patient with a BRCA2 germline mutation had been treated for a stage IIA ER+,PgR-,HER2- breast cancer in 04/2018. Seven months after her treatment was completed (chemotherapy, surgery, radiation, bilateral adnexectomy) and while on tamoxifen, she was admitted with a left sided hemiparesis, due to newly diagnosed brain metastasis. Blood tests showed an important anemia (Hb 8.1 gr/dL), thrombocytopenia (59x109/mL, high D-dim levels (6401 mg/dL), low fibrinogen (49 mg/dL), unmeasurable haptoglobin and the presence of schistocytes, all of which are compatible with a tumor related DIC and hemolytic anemia. She was shown to have also limited bone metastases, and a solitary brain lesion. CTCs were elevated at 900/7.5mL. Treatment with low molecular weight heparin (LMWH) was without effect on the coagulation tests. Only after initiation of effective platinum based chemotherapy did the blood results improve, an effect that occurred simultaneously with a fall in CTC count (34/7.5 mL), 10 days after initiation of treatment (Figure 3).
Prospective cohort (n=92)
One hundred and four patients with MBC were prospectively enrolled in a comparative CTC enumeration study called “P1133”. As one of the secondary endpoints in that study, coagulation studies (aPTT, PT, Fibrinogen and D-dimers) were systematically performed synchronous with the CTC enumeration sampling. Twelve patients with thromboembolic events and/or any type of anticoagulative therapy were excluded from the current analysis. Clinical details are summarized in Table 3. Median age was 63 years (range 34-97), nearly 4 out 5 patients suffered from ER+/HER2- disease and one in three patients presented ab initio with stage IV disease. Only 17% had received prior chemotherapy for metastatic disease. Median follow-up was 210 days (range: 15-751). Median overall survival has not been reached. The CellSearch® CTC count had a median of 4 tumor cells/7.5 mL (range: 0 - 2289). This cohort of patients had in general less advanced disease both with regard to extent of disease and number of prior treatment regimens.
Correlation between CTC and OS
The prognostic significance of baseline CTC count (< or ≥ 5 CTC /7.5mL) was confirmed in this cohort with a logrank HR of 4.167 (p< 0.0001). (Figure 4A).
Correlation between ln D-dim and OS
The levels of D-dimer ranged between 100 and 30000 ng/mL with a median of 1125 ng/mL. Increasing levels of fibrin degradation are associated with a shortened OS. (R2 =0.252, p< 0.0001). Median OS differed with borderline statistical significance according to the median D-dim (135 days versus 650 days) with a logrank HR of 2.095 (0.917-4.799) (p=0.068).
Correlation between CTC and D-dim level
Also in this cohort a striking linear correlation is observed between CTC enumeration and D-dimer level (R2 0.3354, p<0.0001) (Figure 4C).
Correlation between CTC and platelet count (PLT).
The platelet count varied between 43 and 424.109/mL with a median value of 242. The PLT level was correlated with the ln transformed CTC level ( p< 0.004, R2= 0.1902) (Figure 4D).
Correlation between D-dim and PLT
An inverse association between platelet count (PLT) (109/mL) and ln D-dimers (ng/mL) is also present in this cohort (Figure 4E) (R2 =0.1947, p<0.001).
Correlation between extracellular vesicles (ECV) and CTC
A significant correlation exists between ln CTC count and ln ECV with a p< 0.001 and R2 of 0.740. (Figure 5A). The ECV count is also positively related to the D-dimers in an univariate analysis with R2 =0.4160 ( p< 0.0001). In a multiple regression analysis, relating both CTC and ECV with the D-dimers as the dependent variable, the addition of the tdEVs data failed to contribute significantly. Number of tdEVs significantly predicted OS (Figure 5B).
Univariate and Multivariate analysis for OS
In the univariate analysis, the performance status, visceral disease, number of lines of chemotherapy (0-1 vs 2+), CTC ≥ 5 CTC /7.5mL, the levels of D-dimers and ECV, serum LDH, HER2 status and ER status were significantly associated with overall survival. Age, platelet count, and fibrinogen level were not.
In multivariate analysis only CTC ≥ 5 CTC /7.5mL, ER status, HER2 status and lines of chemotherapy were associated with OS.