Short-term co-culture does not affect expression of fibroblast markers
To determine if short-term co-culture of fibroblasts with MyLa cells alters the phenotype of normal fibroblasts, we assessed for changes in fibroblast markers by quantitative gene expression analysis. Mesenchyme-specific genes such as vimentin (VIM), alpha-smooth muscle actin (ACTA2) and heat-shock protein 47 (HSP47) were tested, and were unchanged in normal fibroblasts after co-culture with MyLa cells (Fig. 3A). ACTA2 is used as a marker for cancer-associated fibroblasts (CAFs) in solid tumors (28), and is associated with worse clinical outcome for several cancers including breast and lung cancers(29, 30). In co-culture studies of MF fibroblasts with CTCL cells, ACTA2 expression in MF fibroblasts after short-term co-culture was unchanged compared to normal fibroblasts (Fig. 3B). The fibroblasts in MF differ in ACTA2 expression compared to CAFs from carcinomas, including breast, ovarian, pancreatic, and colorectal cancer where expression of ACTA2 is elevated.
In addition, we also measured cellular senescence by quantifying SA-βGal activity, and found that co-culture with MyLa cells did not induce a detectable senescence phenotype in normal fibroblasts (Fig. 3C). Therefore, short-term co-culture of MyLa cells with normal fibroblasts does not induce any change in fibroblasts in terms of phenotypic markers expression and proliferation capacity.
Normal fibroblasts alter expression of CTCL biomarkers in CTCL cells
Expression of TWIST1 and TOX is frequently increased in tumor T cells from CTCL patients (31, 32). Therefore we assess known CTCL cell lines MyLa, Hut78 and HH for expression of TWIST1 and TOX. Of the three cell lines analyzed, only Myla cells expressed these CTCL biomarker genes (Fig. 3D), indicating that abnormal gene expression similar to that seen in patient-derived T cells is preserved MyLa cells.
To study the influence of the ME in CTCL, MyLa cells were co-cultured with normal fibroblasts (n=3) or MF lesional fibroblasts (n=3), and changes in the expression of CTCL biomarker genes in MyLa cells were assessed. As shown in Fig. 3D, MyLa cells have endogenously high TWIST1 expression, but after co-culture with normal fibroblasts, expression of TWIST1 was significantly reduced (p<0.0006) (Fig. 4A). TOX expression was also suppressed in MyLa cells after co-culture (p<0.03) (Fig. 4B).
In contrast, co-culturing MyLa cells with MF lesional fibroblasts increased expression of both TWIST1 and TOX (Fig. 4A-B). As TOX plays an important role in CTCL proliferation (33) and T cell exhaustion (34), the ability of normal fibroblasts to suppress TOX expression in MyLa cells suggests that fibroblasts in the MF TME may have a role in regulating T cell exhaustion and disease progression.
Normal fibroblasts promote a Th1 phenotype in CTCL cells
The effect of the co-culture model on the expression of IFNg and TBX21 in MyLa cells was examined because TWIST1 has been shown to limit the expression of IFNg and TBX21 in Th1 cells (35). Co-culture of MyLa cells with normal fibroblasts increased the expression of both IFNg (p<0.03) and TBX21 (Fig. 4C-D). TBX21 encodes T box transcription factor (T-bet), a master-regulator of Th1 differentiation (36). Given the modulatory role of TWIST1 in Th1 differentiation (35), the increased expression of IFNg and TBX21 may be secondary to TWIST1 suppression in MyLa cells co-cultured with normal fibroblasts. In contrast, culturing MyLa cells with MF tumor-derived fibroblasts further suppressed expression of IFNg and TBX21 in MyLa cells (Fig. 4C-D). These findings suggest that normal fibroblasts promote Th1 cell transcriptional network in MyLa cells.
Normal fibroblasts attenuatesTh2-dominant microenvironment and reduces proliferation
Studies have shown that T-bet not only promotes Th1 cell differentiation, but also represses Th2 differentiation by suppressing GATA3 expression (37) and reducing the binding of GATA3 to DNA (35). GATA3 is crucial for the differentiation of naïve CD4+ T cells into Th2 cells. Furthermore, GATA3 deletion permits the development of IFN-gproducing cells (38). Therefore, we analyzed whether GATA3 expression in MyLa cells is affected by co-culture with fibroblasts. After co-culture with normal fibroblasts, GATA3 expression was suppressed in MyLa cells (p<0.02) (Fig. 5A). In MF, GATA3 is increased, and in MyLa cells after co-culture with MF tumor-derived fibroblasts, GATA3 expression was further upregulated (Fig. 5A).
Several cytokines that are upregulated in advanced CTCL, such as IL-16, can augment the growth of malignant T cells in an autocrine manner (39). IL-16, a potent T-cell chemoattractant, is one of the known marker of MF onset and stage (39). Based on the role of IL-16 as a regulator of T-cell proliferation and migration, we next examined IL-16 expression in MyLa cells in co-culture experiments. After co-culture with normal fibroblasts, a significant suppression in IL-16 expression was observed (p<0.03) (Fig. 5B). In contrast, co-culture with MF tumor-derived fibroblasts increased IL16 expression in MyLa cells (Fig. 5B). We next assessed the role of co-culture on genes important in proliferation by assessing expression of MK167. We observed reduced MK167 expression in MyLa cells when co-cultured with normal fibroblast, whereas little effect on MKI67 expression was observed when co-cultured with MF tumor-derived fibroblasts (Fig. 5C). It suggests a differential effect on MK167 by normal fibroblasts versus MF fibroblasts.